JEFF WINTER'S MIDWEEK CARLING CUP REVIEW
MAJOR TALKING POINTS FROM CHELSEA v NEWCASTLE, TOTTENHAM v ARSENAL, STOKE v FULHAM Jeff Winter: 24 September 2010
The Carling Cup threw up some surprises, none bigger than the demise of Chelsea, Liverpool and Everton, but it also created some talking points. Here is my take on the midweek action.
There seemed some soft penalties, questions as to why players stayed on the field and some inconsistencies from game to game as players saw red and others escaped the ultimate sanction.
Article continues below...
Chelsea looked as if they were going to get out of jail at Stamford Bridge as they were awarded a very soft looking penalty. Obviously Phil Dowd clearly saw something that no one else did as Alex went to ground for whatever reason which enabled Chelsea to score form the spot.
You could argue that justice was done when Ameobi scored a late winner for the Toon, however Ryan Taylor who scored one of Newcastle�s goals was very fortunate to still be on the pitch as he had earlier been cautioned for a very reckless challenge. It was one you might say could have been a red in itself.
He then committed another offence which you would feel, had he not already been booked, he would have received a yellow card for. That does not make it right and he should have walked.
It was apparent that the refs from the Football League were a little more severe than their Premier League colleagues. Notts County�s Chilvers was dismissed for holding in the box whereas the hapless Lee Probert took no action in the Spurs v Arsenal game when he adjudged to penalties that had to have been denying obvious goal scoring opportunities.
I always look at things from a ref�s perspective. Old habits die hard, but I just cannot get away with Probert. In my humble opinion he is just not up to the Premier League level. Obviously others think differently though and his face must fit.
The first penalty was generous at best. Bassong may have got the merest of touches on Nasri but he certainly made the most of it. As I said though, if it was a foul it had to be a red card as well. Spurs equaliser in normal time looked suspicious to me as Robbie Keane may well have been offside before scoring.
On a night where Portsmouth�s Richard Hughes was sent off for swearing, the Spurs defenders were very fortunate to stay on the field. No one likes to see players sent off for innocuous offences but if we are going to have any degree of consistency then it has to be the same for everyone.
Rightly or wrongly a couple of teams are picking up a reputation for foul play. I am sure their supporters and indeed managers will say that they are just committed but the tackle by Stoke City�s Andy Wilkinson in added time with his side leading 2-0 against Fulham was both unnecessary and dangerous.
Mis-timed perhaps rather than malicious but the player was only yellow carded. Surely the Rugby League rule, of referring incidents such as these to a review panel would benefit the game?
Bowyer and Fellaini shoud have walked last weekend and if players knew that they could be sanctioned post match and more severely then perhaps they might just curb their actions.
A GUARANTEED PROFIT OF AT LEAST £55.00 ON DENMARK v ENGLAND
There's a whole host of international friendly fixtures this midweek and did you know that it is possible to win money on Wednesday evening's clash between Denmark and England, whatever the result?
The game kicks off at 7.15pm UK Time and we can guarantee you a profit of at least £55.00, whatever the result of the match. All you have to do is follow the simple instructions below and then sit back and enjoy the game. At full-time, you will be at least £55.00 better off, whatever the result of the match.