JEFF WINTER'S WEEKEND REVIEW
MAJOR TALKING POINTS AT MANCHESTER CITY, SPURS, BIRMINGHAM AND WIGAN Jeff Winter: 5 October 2010
A worthy red card this weekend for a horrendous challenge but there were many other tackles that also were not far being a red. This is a subject that I have touched on before and I am amazed that the FA, and indeed the PFA, have not been more vocal about it.
Perhaps we the fans are also partly to blame. We demand wholehearted performances from our players and we all expect our midfielders especially to get stuck in.
Article continues below...
Indeed, a roar of approval meets every bone crunching tackle. In recent years though the commitment has resulted in players making dangerous challenges, under the auspices of �I got the ball�. That is often the cry of the pundits, themselves players from an age where as long as you got the slightest of touches on the ball whatever happened as well was immaterial.
Nowadays the laws and their interpretation are much more severe. A player who makes a reckless challenge should be cautioned. If it is with excessive force and endangers the safety of an opponent then they should be sent off.
As a young player we were always coached to stay on our feet, the reasoning being once you went to ground if you did not get the ball you were out of the game and an opponent could then leave you grounded and make his progress.
In going into a challenge, once both feet are off the ground gravity takes over. You have absolutely no control over your body. Whatever gets in the way is going to get hit, whether it is ball, opponent or both.
Wolves have picked up a bit of a reputation this season, despite Mick McCarthy�s attempts to deflect the criticism. The behaviour of his captain Karl Henry does not help the cause. He has previous and, like Sunderland�s Lee Cattermole, appears to be finding it impossible to learn from his previous misdemeanours.
His challenge on Wigan�s Jordi Gomez could have finished the opponent�s career; it was more by luck than good management that the player was not seriously injured.
At Eastlands we did see a bad injury as Newcastle United�s Ben Arfa suffered a broken leg in two places following a challenge by Manchester City�s Nigel De Jong. The ref, Martin Atkinson, did not even penalise the player. Toon manager Chris Hughton described it as a challenge that he need not have made.
I would argue he had every right to make a challenge, but not one where he threw him into, winning the ball but with no option other than for his trailing leg to clatter into the player which led to the nasty injury sustained.
Whilst the silence has been deafening from Eastlands and from our own domestic FA, it was pleasing to see that Holland manger Bert van Marwijk has publicly condemned the challenge and announced that as a result of it, De Jong will not be in the Dutch squad for the forthcoming internationals.
Sooner or later refs, the authorities and the players union will outlaw these type of challenges. No one wanted to stop tackling, that in itself just leads to more shirt tugging, but the two feet off the ground kamikaze tackles have to be stopped.
Equally as galling but not usually as dangerous are the cynical fouls, as witnessed at White Hart Lane, when Villa�s James Collins deliberately clipped Aaron Lennon�s ankles to prevent him breaking clear. Not denial of an obvious goal scoring opportunity but worthy of something more than a yellow card.
If only we had sin bins in football, offences like that could be dealt with immediately, with advantage going numerically to the sinned against in that game, rather than the culprits eventually getting suspended later on in the season.
I witnessed a similar act of cynicism from Hearts Ian Black as he clipped Rangers Jelavic as he left him stranded. The Rangers man was injured by the foul and left the field shortly afterwards. Justice was perhaps done, result wise, as from another foul Rangers scored their equaliser and eventually went on to win the game.
It does not always work out that way and the cheats need to be punished more severely.
Birmingham City lost their long unbeaten home record at St.Andrews as Everton took the points. It might have been different though had The Blues been awarded a penalty when Baines fouled Carr in the penalty area when it was 1-0 and also, with the scoreline still the same, Seamus Coleman handled the ball in the box.
Another team to feel aggrieved this weekend was Newcastle United at Eastlands against Manchester City. Apart from the broken leg suffered by Ben Arfa, they conceded a penalty for not only a genuine challenge that appeared to take the ball but also where the contact was outside the box.
The ref would not have had a good view, but surely his near side assistant could have helped him more, as indeed he could have done when Ameobi was caught by Lescott. Admittedly he did not help himself with his exaggerated fall but he was caught and, soft or not, should have resulted in a spot kick.
At Anfield Liverpool�s woes continue. Blackpool were full value for their win and God knows why Johnson was complaining after conceding a penalty kick. As the experts say, that definitely was a �stone-waller�!
Have a good week.
A GUARANTEED PROFIT OF AT LEAST �41.00 ON ASTON VILLA v TOTTENHAM HOTSPUR
The Christmas Premier League programme starts on Sunday now and did you know that it is possible to win money on the Boxing Day evening clash between Aston Villa and Tottenham Hotspur, whatever the result?
The game kicks off at 5.30pm UK Time and we can guarantee you a profit of at least �41.00, whatever the result of the match. All you have to do is follow the simple instructions below and then sit back and enjoy the game. At full-time, you will be at least �41.00 better off, whatever the result of the match.