JEFF WINTER'S WEEKEND REVIEW
MAJOR TALKING POINTS AT CELTIC, SPURS, STOKE AND MANCHESTER CITY Jeff Winter: 26 October 2010
Another weekend and more debatable offside decisions, dubious penalty decisions and the annoying habit of players surrounding referees asking for opponents to be cautioned or sent off.
Referees are supposed to take action against players who wave imaginary cards suggesting that they take disciplinary action against opponents and I wish that they would. OK, the card count would increase and players may end up being sent off, but try explaining to me that these pathetic acts are not worse than excessively celebrating goals.
Article continues below...
In the Manchester City v Arsenal game, referee Mark Clattenburg who had a very good game, was surrounded in the first five minutes by Arsenal players led by captain Cesc Fabregas pathetically pleading for the Manchester City defender to be sent off.
Don�t get me wrong, Arsenal are no better or worse than any other team as rarely a game goes by without players behaving like spoilt children telling tales.
At Celtic Park, much of the same, with players of both sides hounding the ref throughout the game, not only contesting decisions but suggesting strongly to Willie Collum that opponents should be sent off. In a game as fierce as this one the last thing a ref needs is to caution players for this when tackles are flying in left right and centre.
However the growing trend needs to ended, a few cards consistently issued might dissuade dissent and stop the childish behaviour.
Some might say, no - will say, that if refs did not make mistakes there would be no dissent. Bollocks - dissent happens all the time regardless of whether the decision is right or wrong. The habit of pressuring officials to make decisions is pathetic but the laws don�t help with a player getting a yellow for something technical and the same punishment for a physical foul.
Both aspects are wrong and need dealing with but the game would be better if the refs were left to make their own decisions rather than being 'helped' and 'encouraged' by a posse of whinging players.
At Celtic Park there was another debatable penalty decision, albeit when the game appeared to be slipping away from the home side. Kirk Broadfoot invited the contact. Nothing new; an act perfected by Christian Ronaldo at Manchester United.
Players now wait for the defender to commit themselves then turn into them drawing contact and giving the referee a very difficult call. From high in the Lisbon Lions Stand it looked a penalty but having seen it again in slow motion I am not so sure.
In the Stoke v Manchester United game, Gary Neville was very fortunate not to see red. Having already been cautioned he lunged into a challenge that deserved a sending off. In the same game Evra should have had a penalty when Rory Delap fouled him.
Liverpool managed to win at home to Blackburn Rovers but their margin of victory could have been greater as Kyrgiakos was barged off the ball as he tried to head it.
West Brom v Fulham and a couple of goals that showed how difficult it is for assistant referees. The first Albion goal was good but the margin for error was minute as the first West Brom goal needed a slide rule slow motion replay to prove that the official got it right.
The second goal was one of those second phase situations that managers, including Fulham�s Mark Hughes, just cannot grasp. Fortune was in an offside position in the build up and clearly benefitted by his initial position, as indeed did Rangers Kenny Miller for the Bears second goal, but they are not committing an offence no matter what we all think.
At White Hart Lane, Yakubu did what he does well - I know having watched him at Boro - in making the most of any minimal contact. He bought the free kick that led to Leighton Baines giving Everton the lead.
In the Wigan v Bolton game Di Santos was offside, with the assistant being beaten by the sheer pace of the incident.
So it�s dead easy, Ban offsides, book all players who ask for opponents to be disciplined and get every penalty decision right. Perfect games, perfect officials, utopia.
It�s not going to happen!
Have a good week.
A GUARANTEED PROFIT OF AT LEAST �41.00 ON ASTON VILLA v TOTTENHAM HOTSPUR
The Christmas Premier League programme starts on Sunday now and did you know that it is possible to win money on the Boxing Day evening clash between Aston Villa and Tottenham Hotspur, whatever the result?
The game kicks off at 5.30pm UK Time and we can guarantee you a profit of at least �41.00, whatever the result of the match. All you have to do is follow the simple instructions below and then sit back and enjoy the game. At full-time, you will be at least �41.00 better off, whatever the result of the match.
bhoywunda, October 26, 2010 at 2:26 pm we know your a hun winters "i am not so sure" it was blatantly the wrong decision and the ref didnt even see it dont pretend it was a minor mistake and an honest one JH1967, October 26, 2010 at 3:59 pm was it lonely in the borders at teesside park on christmas eve 2008 waiting for people to buy your book, and no one came, no one came. I was sat in the north stand and you could see it wasnt a penalty from there, the ref didnt witness the incident and shouldnt give it based on the aftermath, whether it was a penalty or not. kevbhoy88, October 26, 2010 at 7:24 pm this man called aiden mcgeady a cheating bastard when he was fouled by lee mculloch in the final old firm game last season resultng in a red card well jeff is broadfoot a cheating bastard? you are biased beyond belief and your opinions dont matter to anyone but the rest of the laptop loyal to anyone reading this the referees back was turned he didnt see broadfoot dive didnt consult his linesman but somehow still gave a penalty and i sat further away than jeff and could see it wasnt a pen