JEFF WINTER'S WEEKEND REVIEW
MAJOR TALKING POINTS AT SPURS, WEST HAM, CHELSEA AND ASTON VILLA

Jeff Winter: 18 November 2010

jeff winter

I was travelling up to Glasgow when the Villa v Manchester United game was on so I listened to the Five Live commentary. Alan Green was slaughtering ref Mike Dean and I, like any other listener, assumed the ref was having a mare!

He said Wes Brown and Vidic should have been sent off, so it was either the ref being kind to United or just perhaps Green is anti- Manchester United or, unbelievably, unaware of the laws. By the time I watched the game and listened to the post-match comments it was obvious that, not for the first time, Mr Green had been totally over the top with his hysterical commentary.

Article continues below...



No complaints with the penalty, clear cut, but it was not a sending off in my book. There was another United player making a challenge at the same time as Brown brought him down so obviously there was a covering defender.

Ashley Young got cautioned for excessive goal scoring celebrations; he actually jumped over the hoardings and went into the crowd. Along with most other people I think that it is a ridiculous rule that players have to be cautioned. OK, if they are intimidating opposing fans or doing something that can create danger but I would suggest jumping into the crowd, which causes people to rush forward, is going a little too far.

Green�s problem was that Vidic escaped a caution, which would have been his second. He crucified Dean for inconsistency. Whilst he rushed towards his own supporters he did not go into the crowd.

The bottom line is that players should stay on the pitch and keep their shirts on, then they won�t pick up unnecessary cautions.

In the Spurs v Blackburn game the home side finally got a penalty after having a couple of stone wallers turned down recently. Then what do they do - miss it. Rather kills the argument that refs not giving teams penalties changes the course of games, doesn�t it?

They should have had one even earlier when Modric was caught but his pathetic fall probably convinced the ref it was not a foul.

Liverpool�s recent up turn in fortunes came to an end at Stoke City where the home side once again could feel aggrieved over a couple of refereeing decisions. Penalty areas are a free for all. With so much going on, free kicks to the defence or penalties could be given at virtually every corner or free kick.

It is not as easy for the officials to spot who is doing what to who. We get the benefit of TV cameras focussing in on the main culprits.

That being said, someone should have spotted the couple of assaults that took place By Maxi on Fuller and Skrtel on Huth. The ref though had no option but to march Lucas for a couple of frustrated challenges. I don�t suppose too many Liverpool fans will miss him whilst he is suspended.

At West Ham it was goal-less against Blackpool but the game certainly did not lack incident. The Hammers should have had a penalty when Cathcart not only handled the ball but actually saved a shot on goal.

God knows how Kevin friend missed that one as it was fairly obvious. His assistant did no better either when ruling out a Marvin Harewood goal. He was clearly not offside when he fired past Green.

There were a couple of arguments over whether players should have been sent off for denying obvious goal scoring opportunities. At Everton I think Howard Webb was correct in only cautioning Squillaci as the Everton player was not clean through on goal but if only he had waited a split second before blowing he could have played the advantage and Everton would have scored.

At Stamford Bridge it did not matter in the end as Chelsea were turned over by Sunderland, but should Ivanovic have been sent off? It was a cynical foul, worth perhaps more than a yellow on moral grounds alone, but hard to describe it as an obvious goal scoring opportunity as the Sunderland striker was not in possession of the ball.

I would not have complained if he had red carded him though, purely for the cynicism of the challenge.

Have a good week.





Back To Jeff Winter Index

Click here to order a copy of Jeff's autobiography

Click here to read all of Jeff's regular articles and to write to Jeff...


Send this to a friend


COMMENTS ON THIS ARTICLE

Be the first to comment on this article

 
Name:
Email:
Your Comment:




© All written site content is copyright SportingPreview.com 2010-2011, unless otherwise stated, and is not to be used without prior permission.
   Search Site | Terms and Privacy | Set as Homepage | Contact
Web Statsrestore file