JEFF WINTER'S WEEKEND REVIEW
MAJOR TALKING POINTS AT SPURS, ASTON VILLA, BOLTON AND WEST HAM Jeff Winter: 30 November 2010
The weather did not harm the Premier League programme but it's bloody freezing up in the north east. If it does not improve by the weekend we will lose a lot of games nationwide.
This burst of arctic conditions just proves what a farce it would be if we did have a mid season winter break. You just cannot rely on the weather and we could have games off when the weather is good through the break then lose fixtures when the weather does worsen, resulting in a fixture backlog.
Article continues below...
The new craze is for defensive walls to fancy themselves as goalkeepers. Following Cesc Fabregas recently, David N�Gog lifted his arms when in the defensive wall and gifted Spurs a penalty. People often say that if the ref fails to award a spot kick it costs the side a possible victory. Not if Jermaine Defoe is taking it.
His weak and wide effort failed to capitalise on the Liverpool�s striker's moment of madness. That apart it was a cracking end to end game also proving that player misses and errors have more effect on the result of the game than any individual refereeing error. Liverpool had the chances to have killed the game off long before Spurs got going.
Fulham v Birmingham, the home side got a point after scoring following a corner kick that wasn�t, the Birmingham boss felt aggrieved but they still had the chance to defend it. Having said that they would not have had to if the assistant had not incorrectly signalled the ball out of play.
Blackpool threw away a two goal lead at the Reebok and during the game Ian Holloway�s player Vaughan committed a cynical trip on an opponent. This type of cynicism should warrant more than a yellow card. It is not mistimed but is a form of cheating, maybe not worthy of a red card, but if only we had sin bins that would punish the culprits more appropriately.
Arsenal v Aston Villa was a goal thrilled encounter with yet again a major talking point regarding the stupid interpretations of offside that the officials have to contend with. John Carew was stood directly in front of Fabianski, you see him bending and stooping to one side to try and see past him. If that was not interfering with an opponent then I do not know what is.
The problem is the assistant can see a player is in an offside position but cannot judge if he is in the vision of an opponent. The referee has a much better chance of doing that as he is facing play. Earlier this season Mike Dean did exactly that when awarding a Spurs Tom Huddlestone a goal, when he could see that the forward in an offside position was not interfering. This has to work in reverse, the assistant should flag and then the ref can decide. Bottom line is that the goal should not have stood.
Wolves v Sunderland saw a couple of offside situations and the first one the officials got correct. Stearman was offside when turning the ball into the net. It looks strange because the keeper was not the last defender but as he rushed out there was only one other defender between Stearman and the goal.
The officials got the next one wrong though. In the build up to the goal the ball was played forward to a player in an offside position who played the ball in that position so the flag should have gone up and therefore the goal would not have happened.
West Ham v Wigan, a late goal for the visitors may not have altered the result but it was chalked off for offside and should have stood. The scorer was not offside; he was being played on by a defender who had not moved out quickly enough.
Everton surprisingly were thumped at home by West Brom whose cause was not helped by the sending off of Mikel Arteta. The Spaniard had no cause for complaint as he clearly stamped on an opponent, but it was rank bad refereeing that led to the sending off.
Ref Lee Mason, missed a dangerous challenge by Jara. He appeared to have a clear view of his aerial challenge but failed to penalise him for it. In the immediate continuation of play, it was obvious that players reacted to the initial challenge.
The ref had chance to stop play before anything escalated, as another rash challenge was made on Jara. The game needed stopping before the obvious happened, another rash challenge and the reaction of Arteta. The ref comes out of this with no credit at all. He missed the initial challenge then missed an opportunity to stop play soon after.
In the same game we saw the stupid result of a player getting himself booked for over celebrating a goal. Mulumbu picked up a second yellow card for a foul seconds after his needless card for running into his fans to celebrate.
I have stated on numerous occasions that it is a ridiculous rule, but the players know it�s there and foolishly continue to pick up yellow cards, then in the case of the idiot make another rash challenge soon after.
Have a good week.
A GUARANTEED PROFIT OF AT LEAST �38.60 ON WEST HAM v BIRMINGHAM
It's the Carling Cup semi-finals first leg this midweek and did you know that it is possible to win money on Tuesday evening's clash between West Ham and Birmingham, whatever the result?
The game kicks off at 7.45pm UK Time and we can guarantee you a profit of at least �38.60, whatever the result of the match. All you have to do is follow the simple instructions below and then sit back and enjoy the game. At full-time, you will be at least �38.60 better off, whatever the result of the match.