JEFF WINTER'S WEEKEND REVIEW
WEBB GOT BOTH MANCHESTER UNITED v LIVERPOOL DECISIONS RIGHT Jeff Winter: 11 January 2011
As was expected, the major talking points of the weekend would be around the Manchester United v Liverpool game. Spice was added to the occasion with the appointment of Kenny Dalglish to replace sacked Roy Hodgson.
The appointment of England's top referee Howard Webb to the game confirmed the game as the tie of the round. No one could have imagined the game would start in such a manner with a penalty appeal within 32 seconds.
Article continues below...
The normal phrases were bandied about by commentators and pundits alike and the consensus of public opinion will, as usual, be dictated by which team you support.
Within minutes of the decision I was receiving emails from the usual Howard Webb hating cowardly toss pot that regularly anonymously makes comments about him. In answer to his pathetic suggestion that perhaps I had an orgasm when Webb received his award in the New Year's Honours List, I can confirm that I did not but juices did flow as I wept a tear of pride for a man who deservedly received recognition for his outstanding service to football and refereeing.
None of that makes him perfect or incapable of human error. The knives would no doubt be out without juvenile accusations that he is a Manchester United fan. As I have advised before his team is Rotherham and he is not allowed to referee them.
Was it a penalty? In my opinion it was. A massive call for the officials but they got it right. Why on earth does Agger make a challenge in that position, when all he has to do is stay on his feet and block the cross? He makes contact with Berbatov and that is enough.
The pundits describe it as minimal, but he does not have to murder him. It was a totally unnecessary challenge and a foul. Whether or not Berbatov makes a meal of it is immaterial. It was a foul.
The pundits suggested that the assistant did not give it. Are they privy to what is said over the referee's communication system?
Having made that major decision so early, Webb faced a second big call when Gerrard dived in. Again he got this one correct as well. As Alladyce and Southgate this time correctly stated, it was a reckless challenge with excessive force. Once a player leaves the ground he has lost control of his body and only gravity or contact with an opponent or the ball will halt his momentum.
Gerrard went in two footed and caught his opponent. Webb took his time and got this one right as well.
A GUARANTEED PROFIT OF AT LEAST £41.25 ON NEWCASTLE UNITED v TOTTENHAM HOTSPUR
There's a full round of Premier League fixtures this weekend and did you know that it is possible to win money on Saturday afternoon's clash between Newcastle United and Tottenham Hotspur, whatever the result?
The game kicks off at 3.00pm UK Time and we can guarantee you a profit of at least £41.25, whatever the result of the match. All you have to do is follow the simple instructions below and then sit back and enjoy the game. At full-time, you will be at least £41.25 better off, whatever the result of the match.
stan, January 11, 2011 at 2:10 pm If you cant aknowledge like 90% of the population does that the penalty was indeed not a penalty then there is one word for you. You are a one eyed D##KHEAD
You moron stop writing rubbish Colie, January 11, 2011 at 2:10 pm Sorry Jeff...tell me something is football a contact sport...Yeah....thought so myself. Therefore contact is to expected. Was it really a foul...No. Agger didn't actually make a challenge he was put a foot across to block what would of been an original cross, only Berbatov knocked the ball on. The contact that was made was 1. Very minimal... and 2. was made as a side on challenge which wouldn't of knocked Berba out of his stride...if he was coming across him maybe. And for Gerrards sending off...you can say yes he deserved red...but can you tell me, how did Mr. Webb miss a blantant foul by Rafael a minute earlier when clearly he made a challenge on Mereleis with a two footed tackle also. charlie, January 11, 2011 at 2:15 pm of course jeff winter say that that webb was right cause both of them likes manure &hate L.F.C..both of you dirty bastard. Fred the red, January 11, 2011 at 2:26 pm Colie, Rafael did take the ball, not the man. Mereiles was not even close to the ball when Rafa got it.
Charlie, you are probably very right in your comments... Everybody hates liverpool and loves Manchester United. Thats why you can't win games anymore... right... Ravaish, January 11, 2011 at 2:35 pm Fred the red: So was it a penalty or not? No by a mile! But it is not true that the media and referees like Howard 'Ferguson's bitch' Web love Man Utd, who knows why with such a mediocre squad you are first?!?! Be honest for once! Al the red, January 11, 2011 at 2:36 pm I absolutely agree Jeff it is the fact that illegal contact was made, and not the degree of contact that is the issue. It has been said that Berbatov went down too easily, the fact of the matter is that, far too often, if a player does not go down in these situations they get nothing. Aodhan Murphy, January 11, 2011 at 2:36 pm Winters is a Mongo. Howard Webb is a Mongo. Celebrity referee's should be banned from the game. They thrive on making the match an attention seeking device to further their celebrity status. Mark, January 11, 2011 at 2:38 pm If Web is the best referee in England then the refs in there are a joke! But it seems that Jeff Winter and Fred the red saw different games than the rest of the once who actually saw the game! Maybe Winter was one of those who wanted Benitez out and was happy with Hodgson's appointment! Who knows! Fred the red, January 11, 2011 at 2:45 pm Ravaish: I think Agger did make contact, and wasn't even close to getting the ball. The only thing he wanted to do with his contact was to disturb Berbatov as he could not get in front of him. It might be a bit soft, but still it is by the rules of the game.
That aside, there were 3 more penalty claims from United in that game, most notably the one where Evans was held down during a cornerkick. The other two was with Evra and Giggs. I think it was a bigger mistake by the ref not to give a penalty there, than giving one for Berbatov. Satha, January 11, 2011 at 2:51 pm Webb has awarded 6 penalties in 4 years at old trafford. He was with the South Yorkshire Police when Hillsbrough tragedy occured and the fans are still trying to sue the police force. So, you can understand Webb's penalty award and red card. Satha, January 11, 2011 at 2:53 pm Jeff Winter? Is he the one who gave three yellow cards in a world cup match? Yea, his words and judgement are useless! James (United), January 11, 2011 at 2:54 pm I agree not a lot of contact, but are you telling me that Steven Gerrard would not have gone down, in fact he doesn�t even need contact to go down (blackburn December 2009)Rafael got the ball and none of the player, if you watch it slowly he lifts his left foot up slightly then puts it down. So if you want to compare that to a two footed lunge with all of his studs showing then you need your eyes tested. Steveo, January 11, 2011 at 3:09 pm Typical of you winter, the fact is he felt a touch then went down as if shot in a delayed reaction which proves it was a dive. No way could Webb could tell from his postion unless he is superhuman vision. Also, the sending of was harsh as he went for the ball and not through the player. Moreover, it depends on standards, i bet a million pounds that Man players like Scholes will throw in similar tackles and there will be no red card. Ps. you should marry mr Webb, you would make an ideal couple, the perfect p**ck for a perfect c**t. SummerIsOver, January 11, 2011 at 3:11 pm Agger hardly touched Berbatov in the back and Berbatov fell as if he was run down by a track. If refs would whistle for every touch, a lot of penalties would be given. But the fact is refs don't whistle for stronger hand pushes. But it easy to defend a fellow ref who made a mistake and changed the course of the game. Lucky he didn't sent off Agger for his diabolical foul. Muru, January 11, 2011 at 3:26 pm Well, Berbatov would win an Olympic Gold medal for that DIVE!
A blatant, blatant dive and Winter is probably just coming out of hibernation, making him unable to see it. Mike Arms, January 11, 2011 at 3:35 pm Yet more nonsense from an official. This sends out the message that if a player feels the slightest of touches in the box they can fall to the ground and win a penalty. This will make any tackles inside the box obsolete if this trend continued. However I suspect it will only happen when Webb is officiating and United are the recipients. The notion that the assistant did not raise his flag but whispered something into his mic is absolute nonsense too. They have a flag for a reason, he didn't use it because it wasn't a penalty. Fred the red, January 11, 2011 at 3:38 pm Do not throw rocks while sitting in a glass house guys...
You got two of Premier League's worst divers in your own team, in Gerrard and Torres. Gerrard's dive for a penalty in the CL final against Milan which got you some peace of silverware was just one of them... Martin Brincat, January 11, 2011 at 4:21 pm The gist is that Howard Webb hardly desrves his mbe especially in view of making a mess of the World Cup final. Why did he not send off N De Jong following the kung fu tackle ? He lost the game soon afterwards...Ironically he sent off StevieG for a much minor offence...so clearly its a case off being strong against LFC and weak in another match.
I also wonder if Mr Webb would have granted a penalty against ManU for such a foul ? Nobody will ever forget the ultra mess Mr Webb did when in April 2009, Manu were losing two nil against Spurs at OT and Mr Webb did an incredible favour to ManU (of course) by granting them an inexistent penalty...should anybody challenges me including you Mr Winter, I can go on and on...the problem is that you in England have two weights and two measures where it regards ManU and the longer you take to admit this defect and tries to rectify it the longer you will remain in the shadow of true world class teams like Barcelona who do not need referees interefering on almost a weekly basis to save their faces. Gere, January 11, 2011 at 8:33 pm That is correct and unbiased!! Let's be neutral when we see things. If it was against United, no one would have argue with that. Metal Mickey, January 11, 2011 at 9:00 pm Satha said;
"Jeff Winter? Is he the one who gave three yellow cards in a world cup match? Yea, his words and judgement are useless!"
That was Graham Poll you fucking dipshit so what does your pathetic comment make YOUR words and opinion worth?