JEFF WINTER'S WEEKEND REVIEW
MAJOR TALKING POINTS AT LIVERPOOL, WOLVES, ARSENAL AND MANCHESTER CITY Jeff Winter: 8 March 2011
As the season comes around to the vinegar strokes it seems that everybody is getting even more tetchy than usual.
Managers are making their post match accusations and comments safe in the knowledge that the weak kneed authorities will take no significant action against them. No one is trying to deny freedom of speech but when the comments are unnecessary and ill-founded, action has to be taken and promptly.
It is the only way it is going to stop the name calling. Sportsmanship is long gone in the game but in recent weeks we have seen an escalation of dissent. Every major decision sees referees or their assistants surrounded by players baying like banshees.
The decision will not be altered, so why bother? Is it to cover up for their OWN mistakes by getting the crowd and the management on the officials' backs rather than accepting their own culpability in what happens on the pitch.
Article continues below...
The referees have to be stronger and take firm action against dissent. Cards have to be produced; cowering behind the "I did not see it" stance is cowardly.
Players will have to learn, OK, a few games will be ruined as sides are depleted, but I don�t see another alternative.
Having returned from holiday I have finally seen the Rooney elbow and I can appreciate that the ref did not see it as it was sly and off the ball. But the world and its brother have seen it now.
The hypocrisy adopted by Manchester United with the comments after the Wolves game by Mike Phelan as opposed to Fergie�s rant after they lost at Chelsea a few days later sums up the attitude prevailing in the game. Before United fans start calling me, it is not anti-United. Next week it will be another team and their players.
The tackles continue to fly in and there should be more red cards. I am not totally convinced that even if refs grow a pair and start dealing even handedly with all players that we will see dissent and suicidal challenges go away but it has to help. Surely the thickest of thick will then realise that they cannot get away with transgressing the laws!
Manchester City hung on to beat Wigan Athletic, their case maybe helped by the fact that Micah Richards received a yellow card as opposed to a red one. The challenge certainly was reckless and made with such speed that the excessive force aspect of the law was certainly applicable and it most certainly endangered the safety of his opponent. He was a lucky man to stay on the field of play.
Arsenal v Sunderland, the visitors held on for a point to stifle the Gunners' title charge. Arsenal could rightly feel aggrieved as a couple of major decisions went against them. The goal that Arshavin scored was ruled out for offside and highlighted how difficult an assistant's job is. Andy Garrett made a split second judgement and on this occasion got it wrong.
The Russian was onside, albeit by inches rather than yards. It certainly wasn�t his day. He was pushed by Titus Bramble in the penalty area and no penalty was given. It was not the fault of the referee as he would be looking through the back of the players and was a long way from Mr Garrett but he was the only one with a view on it from the right angle. Some stated that he was already going down, personally I think not as he was being held outside the box then pushed in it.
Another interesting afternoon for Mark Clattenburg after the controversy of the Rooney off the ball incident. It was an end to end game with many tight decisions and in my opinion Fulham should have had a penalty when Andy Johnson was fouled. Maybe his reputation went against him?
The defender played the Fulham forward and from the side he made his challenge he had little chance of winning the ball fairly. Within seconds they did get a penalty and the experts suggested that whilst it �technically� was a penalty, if that was given there should be many penalties awarded every game.
Now it was not �technically� a penalty - it was a penalty as the defender was holding him back. Yes there should be many every game, but equally they could be many free kicks given towards the defence. I do not know the answer. If refs don�t penalise holding they are criticised if they do give them they are also vilified.
At the vital Birmingham v West Brom game we saw a session of all�in wrestling in the penalty area. The ball was in play, both players were cautioned, but who was the instigator? I don�t know, much the same as holding at corners and free kicks, it is getting impossible to get these decisions right.
One thing that can�t be confused is Lee Bowyers one hundredth yellow card, the greatest number amassed by any player in Premier League history. His look of innocence belied that fact that not all of them could be refereeing overreactions.
Bolton v Villa and Young had his penalty saved, which was justice as in the build up the ball had gone out of play and the game should have been stopped for a throw in before Boro old boys Downing and Wheater clashed for the penalty to be given.
Liverpool v Manchester United was a cracker and a lot more one sided than anyone could have guessed. The game was somewhat marred by a couple of challenges that deserved red cards and the resultant free for alls that ensued.
Jamie Carragher�s tackle on Nani was high and over the top, as indeed was Rafael�s challenge on the Liverpool player. The ref, Phil Dowd, calmly stayed out of the melees and then issued cards. Maybe the wrong colour though.
Sunday's final game was superb, showing that there is a reduction in the quality between top teams and bottom teams in the Premier League. It had everything that is good about the game but was not without controversy.
Firstly many thought that Alan Hutton should have gone for conceding the penalty that brought about an equaliser for Wolves to make the score 2-2. The pundits went on about last man but I could understand Mark Halsey�s decision not to send the Scot off.
The ball was almost in Gomes� hands and there was no certainty that the Wolves player would have got to it. So therefore, was it an obvious goal-scoring opportunity? That is the question, not that Hutton was the last man.
One decision Halsey did get wrong in my opinion was ruling out what would have been an equalising goal for Wolves. I felt that the erratic Gomes was at fault and that Stearman�s challenge was fair. Regrettably these incidents were the talking points, when the goals and action were the most important aspects of the game. A fitting tribute to the life of Dean Richards who sadly died last week.
The "You�re not fit to referee" chants in the direction of Mark Halsey were ironic as he too has had to fight for his life after contracting throat cancer.
Maybe my last two comments might bring a little sanity to decent readers and put everything into perspective. Despite what Bill Shankly said, football is not more important than life!
Have a good week.
A GUARANTEED PROFIT OF AT LEAST £56.40 ON STOKE CITY v WEST HAM
It's the FA Cup quarter-finals this weekend and did you know that it is possible to win money on Sunday afternoon's clash between Stoke City and West Ham, whatever the result?
The game kicks off at 2.00pm UK Time and we can guarantee you a profit of at least �56.40, whatever the result of the match. All you have to do is follow the simple instructions below and then sit back and enjoy the game. At full-time, you will be at least �56.40 better off, whatever the result of the match.
Andrew, March 8, 2011 at 1:27 pm I haven't seen the Hutton incident yet but reminds me of the hoo-ha over our centre back, Boyata, who was wrongly sent off in our Man City home game against Arsenal when, in my opinion, he didn't touch the player and certainly did not prevent a goal scoring chance as the player claiming the foul, Chamakh, was on the corner edge of the area and had pushed the ball so far forward that Hart was hot favourite to get their long before he did. So Halsey gets the benefit of the doubt one way and the attacking team get it in our match the other way. The problem is that the decision is subjective and one referee will see it one way and the following week another one sees a similar incident differently. Halsey, is in my opinion, an excellent referee and although that decision and the disallowed goal became the talking points, he handled the game overall very well and they were not decisions that you could argue he was clearly in the wrong over. Some people agreed with him and some didn't. That's football. As for the red cards that weren't handed out, got to say that Richards, Carragher and Rafael can thank the referees for their leniency. They were all late, the intent was there. Craig, March 8, 2011 at 2:50 pm Geoff, if you look at the Milijas/Hutton incident again, you will see that Milijas touches the ball even though he is pulled back, so there is no doubt that he would have got to the ball before Gomez.