| MAIN MENU |
|
|
 |
|
|
|
THE THOMAS McAVOY COLUMN
CHELSEA ISSUE HIGHLIGHTS UNFAIRNESS OVER YOUTH
Thomas McAvoy, 22 Sep 2009
A precedent has been set.
Placing a two transfer window long transfer embargo upon Chelsea must, more than anything, act as a deterrent to the clubs who have long since manipulated conflicting laws in European countries regarding the age at which players can turn professional.
Premier League clubs had been in an advantageous position regarding this.
Both in Italy and Spain, prospective professionals are unable to sign professional contracts until their eighteenth birthday.
In England, professional contracts can be signed at sixteen.
Column Continues Below...
However, the move has more than set a precedent, it has brought to light the issue of youth development and the ethics of the free movement of youngsters to centralised regions of talent within the football market.
Football, like all other industries, is constantly globalising.
Clubs at the top level of football are able to create scouting networks that cover each and every continent in all areas of the globe that football has infiltrated.
They may even be able to create ties with certain regions, perhaps by setting up their own academies in India or China where the popularity of football, as well as the populations, are expanding.
Feeder clubs are also prominent.
For over a decade, Manchester United sent players out on loan to Antwerp in Belgium, the deal stipulating that the youngsters would be guaranteed regular first team football in a relatively competitive environment.
Likewise, Arsenal have links to Beveren, a side which had a huge quota of players shipped in from the Ivory Coast. Emanuel Eboue and Kolo Toure owe their time at Arsenal to this relationship.
It is this globalisation of football, in conjunction with conflicting contract laws, that has meant that English teams have been able to poach the cream of European talent.
Scouts representing English clubs will convene at events such as the UEFA youth tournaments in order to keep tabs on those who most catch the eye.
Not only has the enticement of signing a professional contract at one of the world's most glamorous clubs attracted the cream of the European crop to English academies. Clubs are astute - they offer sweeteners to the deal.
Parents may be persuaded by the promise of a home and a job to go to.
Perhaps the club will provide transport to the family.
And of course there's the dream of playing in what is marketed as the best league in the world.
Compared with any other club in the world, excluding Barcelona and Real Madrid (although even their statuses weren't enough to dissuade Pique, Merida or Fabregas from joining English clubs upon their sixteenth birthdays), the English Big Four offer greater wages and guaranteed Champions League football.
It's not difficult to see why the players see their names in lights as they cross the English Channel, is it?
The main proponents of the purchasing of young talent are the Big Four, although they are not exclusive to this.
Liverpool's Melwood academy has produced a number of graduates who were not born in the British Isles. They were thus tempted to sign professional terms on Merseyside rather than with the youth systems in the homelands that nurtured and developed them.
Thirty percent of Chelsea's academy players, according to that paragon of virtue and definite-not-waste-of-money, Frank Arnesen, are imported.
Furthermore, a quick look at Arsenal's academy development under Arsene Wenger unveils a reliance on imports.
A quick glance at their League Cup teams of the past decade also reveals that the river which floods into the academy soon dries into a trickle as it nears the holy grail of the first team.
Anybody remember Oli Skulason, Quincy Owusu Abeyie or Daniel Karbassiyoon?
As well as the Pique and Giuseppe Rossi - sporadic appearances half a decade ago belied a talent which is finally burgeoning at Villarreal - it was a player purchased by such means who arguably scored the most important goal of Manchester United's previous championship winning season.
Federico Macheda turned quickly after receiving a through-ball against Aston Villa. He curled the ball into the top corner in the final minute of a game that had been balanced on tenterhooks.
A title winner at the age of seventeen; not bad business for a player who cost nothing in compensation.
It's only natural that the derisory sums of money exchanged between clubs for the signature of the youngsters - indeed, if any money is to be exchanged - leaves a sour taste in the mouths of the victims.
Almost immediately after that famous match winning goal, Lazio representatives were venomous in their criticism of the 'predatory' Manchester United.
Instances when the money to match the potential future values of the players has been paid often invoke perceptions of deception by the propagators.
Take the transfers of Tom Taiwo and Michael Woods from Leeds United to Chelsea in 2005.
Chelsea's expenditure of over �4million for their signatures was not paid through benevolence. It transpires that both players were, whilst in the period of courtship, treated by Frank Arnesen to a match at Stamford Bridge.
And at that game, who should happen to be sitting a few seats away from them, but Leeds Academy's Head of Recruiting?
The compensation was paid to keep Leeds quiet.
It couldn't, however, keep Lens quiet about the ethics of Kakuta's move to London which has brought about the temporary demise of Chelsea.
In fact, it is estimated that under Frank Arnesen's tutelage alone, there has been �62million spent on Academy products.
And of these, who was the last to break through to see their name in lights and to hear their name sung from the Shed?
Perhaps Franco di Santo, signed for �3million from Audax Italiano, or Sergio Terjera, an Espanyol product?
John Terry is the answer. He has been a mainstay in the team since emanating from the youth set up before we realised that the Millenium Dome was a poor investment.
European clubs aren't the sole victims of this vacuuming of talent towards the clubs with the greatest resources and prospects.
Whilst rules stipulate that, before the age of sixteen, players are unable to travel to a training ground over one hour away, thus restricting who they can sign for, beyond that, movement is free.
Call me parochial, but there's something distasteful about regional accents being enticed from local clubs to supplement the droves of youngsters joining the biggest clubs.
Is this centralisation of talent really for the benefit of the players themselves?
It would take only the most deluded of souls not to admit that the proportion of players recruited who make the first teams of the big clubs regularly is tiny.
Wouldn't it be beneficial for players like Kakuta to have stayed in Lens, playing first team football?
Even looking at the best team in the world last season, Pique seems to have wasted a year of potential first team football bumbling about in Manchester United's reserves.
Imagine our surprise when watching Sky and ITV to see a technically accomplished giant of a leader at the heart of Barcelona's defence.
He was surely not the same player as the one who was bullied by Kevin Davies in a pitiful 1-0 defeat in a rare outing eighteen months earlier!
I'm afraid to say he was.
Maybe it would be churlish of me to blame the relative primacy of English training methods, the emphasis of strength over tactical nous, and the lack of technical development, when one of the benefits of imports has been the exchange of European ideas.
We have admittedly hybridised a high tempo, direct, traditional style of football with defensive and attacking collectivisation.
Our teams are much more patient, balanced and lethal on the counter attack.
Our players are tactically attuned, intelligent and responsible. They are able to take orders and, at the right times, break free from the shackles to create match winning goals.
But this doesn't eradicate the fact that footballers will, given the influx of new ideas, develop more quickly into better players given the experience of first team football.
The theory of Moneyball, based on the scouting principles of Oakland A's Major League Baseball manager Billy Beane, partly states that the development of a footballer cannot be fully interpreted until they have reached the age of twenty to twenty-two.
Only then will we be able to discern how truly talented they are.
On that note, surely it is a risk to the player's development to leave the club they have trained with and an environment and pattern of football they are used to, for unlikely notions of fame and fortune.
This is not to mention the plundered academies themselves, angered at the lack of compensation they receive.
In fact, it seems as though the only clubs benefitting from the system are those with the financial scope, the global brand and the power to assert their authority over even national authorities.
Maybe Kakuta's case, whilst questioning the morality of the nature of his transfer, will serve to change the laws regarding the movement of young footballers.
Would a worldwide age restriction on professional contract laws suffice, meaning the Premiership predators would be less inclined to poach from foreign rivals?
Competitive balance, the work the academies put into the players from pre-teen years, and the development of footballers reared from the local area (now there's a novelty) must be protected.
The transfer of players aged below eighteen is an unedifying spectacle of the modern game, favouring only an elite few.
Perhaps it's time to put a stop to it.
COMMENT ON THIS ARTICLE
BACK TO THE THOMAS McAVOY COLUMN
INDEX
A GUARANTEED NO RISK �20.00 FROM BETCLIC
Betclic have come up with the same offer for you and these are by far the best betting offers of the season so far.
Have a bet on any sporting event of �20.00 or more and if your bet loses, you get your �20.00 back.
1. Click here to open an account with Betclic.
2. Have a �20.00 bet on any sporting event you like. You can bet more if you wish, but the refund offer is for up to �20.00.
3. If you bet wins, well done! If your bet loses, you get a �20.00 refund.
You just can't lose with this offer.
CLICK HERE TO OPEN YOUR BETCLIC ACCOUNT AND TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THIS EXCELLENT OFFER
*************************
A GUARANTEED NO RISK �22.00 FROM PAF
And our good friends at PAF have done the same as well.
Have a bet on any sporting event of �22.00 (25eu) or more and if your bet loses, you get your �22.00 back.
1. Click here to open an account with PAF.
2. Have a �22.00 bet on any sporting event you like. You can bet more if you wish, but the refund offer is for up to �22.00.
3. If you bet wins, well done! If your bet loses, you get a �22.00 refund.
You just can't lose with this offer.
CLICK HERE TO OPEN YOUR PAF ACCOUNT AND TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THIS EXCELLENT OFFER
*************************
A GUARANTEED NO RISK �25.00 FROM BETFAIR
Our good friends at Betfair have offered you, our loyal readers, a really great betting offer.
Have a bet on any sporting event of �25.00 or more and if your bet loses, you get your �25.00 back.
1. Click here to open an account with Betfair.
2. Have a �25.00 bet on any sporting event you like. You can bet more if you wish, but the refund offer is for up to �25.00.
3. If you bet wins, well done! If your bet loses, you get a �25.00 refund.
You just can't lose with this offer.
CLICK HERE TO OPEN YOUR BETFAIR ACCOUNT AND TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THIS EXCELLENT OFFER
Comments On This Article
THERE ARE CURRENTLY NO COMMENTS ON THIS ARTICLE
|
|
|
|
| COLUMNISTS |
|
|
 |
|
|