| MAIN MENU |
| SPORTS NEWS |
|
|
|
| DAILY ARTICLES |
|
|
|
| WEEKLY ARTICLES |
|
|
|
| GENERAL ARTICLES |
|
|
|
| MISCELLANEOUS |
|
|
 |
|
|
|
WOULD RANGERS AND CELTIC BE RELEGATED FROM PREMIER LEAGUE IF THEY JOINED?
Betfair, 10 Oct 2009
The subject of Celtic and Rangers disowning their Scottishness and heading to the Premier League has once again reared its head.
Bhoys chief executive Peter Lawwell has claimed that a move would improve Scottish football and allow them to become one of the biggest clubs in the world.
Such grandiose claims got us thinking about how both their and Rangers current squads compare to that of the best, tenth-best and worst current Premier League teams: Chelsea, Everton and Portsmouth. Sadly our findings weren�t too encouraging...
Goalkeepers (Cech, Howard, James, Boruc and McGregor)
Artur Boruc and Allan McGregor are both decent goalkeepers but there�s no shortage of those in the Premier League, as shown by the fact that 18 of the first-choice keepers have been capped internationally (the two exceptions are Manuel Almunia and Brian Jensen trivia fans).
Verdict: Closest to Portsmouth standard
Defensive rocks (Terry, Jagielka, Kaboul, Loovens and Weir)
Rangers� everpresent centre back in the league this season has been 39-year-old David Weir while Celtic�s has been Glenn Loovens, who was signed from Cardiff in 2008. Not quite in John Terry or Phil Jagielka's league but we�ll kindly put them just ahead of Younes Kaboul.
Verdict: Somewhere between Everton and Portsmouth level
Midfield maestros (Lampard, Cahill, Boateng, McGeady and McCulloch)
Despite his unspectacular international form and dive against Hibernian, we like a bit of Aiden McGeady. Lee McCulloch may not be quite so impressive but he had no trouble getting in the Wigan team who overachieved so spectacular after their promotion, before regarding Rangers as a step up.
Verdict: McGeady could probably play for Everton, McCulloch slightly lower
Top scorers (Drogba, Saha, Kaboul, McDonald and Miller)
Kenny Miller may have been the hero of last week�s Old Firm derby but his Premier League record with Wolves and Derby was shoddy � six goals in 55 appearances. Luckily for him, Pompey�s top scorer is Younes Kaboul. Scott McDonald�s SPL goal ratio is great so his progress would be intriguing.
Verdict: More of an attacking threat than Kaboul
The managers (Ancelotti, Moyes, Hart, Mowbray and Smith)
David Moyes is one of the best managers in the country � and actually succeeded struggling Walter Smith at Goodison Park � so neither Old Firm boss can come close. We�re big Tony Mowbray fans but despite bringing style to West Brom, he didn�t actually surpass Bryan Robson�s achievements.
Verdict: Neither would probably get a job at a top ten side
Overall verdict: More likely to be scrapping around 12th and 13th than pushing for Europe.
Reproduced with permission from Betfair Football. (c) The Sporting Exchange Limited.
Click here to join Betfair now
COMMENT ON THIS ARTICLE
BACK TO BETFAIR INDEX
A GUARANTEED PROFIT OF AT LEAST �28.50 ON URUGUAY v ARGENTINA
There's a full round of World Cup qualifying matches this midweek and did you know that it is possible to win money on Wednesday evening's clash between Uruguay and Argentina, whatever the result?
The game kicks off at 11.00pm UK Time and we can guarantee you a profit of at least �28.50, whatever the result of the match. All you have to do is follow the simple instructions below and then sit back and enjoy the game. At full-time, you will be at least �28.50 better off, whatever the result of the match.
A GUARANTEED PROFIT OF AT LEAST �28.50 ON URUGUAY v ARGENTINA
Comments On This Article
Carntyne, October 10, 2009 at 10:40 am With their current squads of players they would be no more than mid-table.
In the current English Premier League neither would the pre-Sky deal old first division Manchester United!
The quality of player of the four teams at the top of the table at the moment is unrecognisable from that of the old first division.
So it would be with the Old Firm player quality if they got their hands on the Sky TV money that the current top four have access to.
That is why it is unlikely that they will be admitted to the Premiership.
Stark fear of the competition they would provide for the League Championship.
JasMcG, October 10, 2009 at 11:12 am Simples, cash.
Give any team Sky money and they would be able to compete.
Don\'t pretend English club football dominance is because of some great \"plan\", it is totally reliant on Sky money - and that won\'t go on forever.
When cash was more equitable between Scotland and England, Scottish teams comepted well, eg Celtic/Leeds 1970, Rangers Leeds 1990s, Celtic Liverpool 2003. Indisputable fact.
A side issue, but relevant. Sky cash for the domestic league means England will never win the World Cup again. Look at the number of English players playing for the top English clubs.
Bhoy67, October 10, 2009 at 12:04 pm Sorry but your article is utter nonsense! With annual Sky income of �30M - two major investors Desmond &O\'Brien ( both billionaires ) Celtic would leave must Premiership clubs in their wake ! Why would you want to play for a debt ridden , regional non entity ( read most of the Premiership ) when you could play for a club like Celtic with global appeal and a history . p.s. Does the fact that Cardiff etc. play in the English League mean they have forsaken their Welshness ? Celtic will always be a Scottish club regardless of where they play.
Dotty, October 10, 2009 at 12:36 pm Possibly the worst written peice of rubbish yet again. What i believe is that English fans don\'t realise how big Rangers and Celtic are and truth be told(something most fans won\'t want to hear) is that Rangers and Celtic are in the same League and Man U and Liverpool. We\'re born to win. And with the money brought in we\'d be in the top 4 easy, ofcourse we wouldn\'t have players like Weir and McCulloch in our teams. I seem to think most people forget that we used to regularly outbid English teams for player and in wages also. Sky Tv is what has created the gulf between our teams.
superally, October 10, 2009 at 2:20 pm Is this another green tinted specs article. Why not compare Loovens with Bougherra, instead of David Wier, and Mc Donald\'s goalscoring with Kris boyd\'s?And Steve Davis, instead of McCulloch?
David Mullen, October 11, 2009 at 1:21 am Typical sloppy anti-Scottish crap !!! Comparing any part of Celtic to portsmouth is an absolute insult,the top four are untouchable at the moment however to say that we couldn\'t finish in the top half and more likely in a Europa League place is just your opinion, i bet you thought five years ago when we played Liverpool and Blackburn off the park to reach the Uefa Cup we would lose also ? does the words merchant banker mean anything to you ?
|
|
|
|
| COLUMNISTS |
|
|
 |
|
|