| MAIN MENU |
| SPORTS NEWS |
|
|
|
| SPECIAL ARTICLES |
|
|
|
| GENERAL ARTICLES |
|
|
|
| MISCELLANEOUS |
|
|
 |
|
|
|
THE STEWART PEARSON COLUMN
MIKE ASHLEY HAS DONE SOME GOOD THINGS AT NEWCASTLE UNITED
Stewart Pearson, 26 Nov 2009
As the team continues to do the job on the pitch, the topic of conversation around Newcastle United has yet again centred on matters off the pitch as animosity still brews between the fans and unpopular tracksuit seller turned football club owner Mike Ashley.
I have resisted talking too much about the running of Newcastle in my first few articles this season but as a Newcastle fan, it�s an unavoidable topic at the moment.
It may not make me popular with my fellow supporters but my views on Mike Ashley are a bit more mixed and open-minded than those of the majority of fans.
Column Continues Below...
I think he has done some good things at the club but these have been overshadowed by quite horrific decision making.
In hindsight, I bet there are quite a few Newcastle fans out there who wish he had never taken over from Freddie Shepherd.
For me, I�m glad he took a punt on buying Newcastle, even though it hasn�t worked out as planned. I say this because I don�t actually think that Mike Ashley has done much worse than Freddie Shepherd would have done had he stayed.
Let�s not kid ourselves here, the club had been stagnant for a good few years before Mr. Ashley came along. It�s not as if Ashley has taken us from Premier League title contenders down into the Championship.
We were a poor mid-table Premier League side that actually flirted with relegation a couple of times under Messrs Shepherd and Souness in the years prior to the takeover. Therefore, I don�t think relegation was as out of the blue as some people would like to make out.
I'd rather be sat here now in the Championship saying Ashley gave it a go and failed than be sat here still moaning about how Freddie Shepherd was still in charge, running the club into the ground. I honestly believe that under Shepherd, we were potentially heading towards a Leeds United type disaster.
I�m in no way trying to let Mike Ashley and his colleagues off the hook here. He has quite clearly made some terrible mistakes, none more so than the Keegan and Wise fiasco which undoubtedly was the trigger of our relegation last season.
However, I�m just trying to put a more balanced slant on things and highlight the fact that things are not necessarily all that bad.
Due to relegation and the Keegan fiasco, people forget some of the good things that his ownership has brought.
Seeing the likes of Nile Ranger, Andy Carroll, Harris Vukic, Tim Krul and Tamas Kadar in and around the first team squad this season is extremely satisfying.
I�d much rather be seeing these guys playing for the club than some of the overpaid primadonnas we have had wearing the shirt in the past and these players are coming through thanks to the investment and emphasis on the academy brought about by the current regime.
Of course, this doesn�t make up for relegation and everything else that has happened. However, I think if people can take off their anti-Ashley glasses for a minute, they may realise that things aren't all bad.
Relegation could turn out to be just what this club needed � a reality check and an opportunity to clear the decks of dead wood in order to re-focus and come again.
It certainly isn�t going too badly at the moment. A team that was tipped to implode and slide down the football pyramid is currently sitting in prime position for an instant return to the Premier League.
Of course, there is still a long way to go but if you had told me at the start of the season that we would be in this position come November, I would have struggled to believe it was possible.
Should we return to the Premier League next season then teams could be turning up to a new ground. Well, the same ground but with a new name!
I am of course talking about the owner�s revelation that not only had he had another change of heart and he was staying in charge for the foreseeable future but he was looking at selling the naming rights to St James� Park.
Again, my feelings on this situation are mixed.
First and foremost, I don�t particularly agree with it but at the same time, I wouldn�t say I was quite as appalled and outraged as some fans appeared to be.
Is it really that bad an idea? At the end of the day, the people who matter (the fans) will always refer to it as St James� Park.
If a company wants to put �Xmillion a year into the club coffers to simply have a few bits of advertising put up around the ground, is that really so bad?
Whether people agree with it or not, modern day football is centred around money. If you want to compete then you need money and I don�t think it�s an unreasonable option to explore all revenue streams in order to help us compete with other clubs.
The counter-argument is that it is destroying part of the club�s heritage. Whilst I can agree with that argument to an extent, is it really going to make that much of a difference?
If we were currently top of the Premier League rather than the Championship then I think the number of people who feel so strongly about this would be far less.
I think Mr. Ashley is now in a position, admittedly through his own doing, where most fans simply won�t like his ideas no matter what they are.
The simple fact is that until somebody can find the money to make a suitable bid for the club, Ashley is here to stay. There is absolutely nothing we can do about this, no matter what we feel about him.
Some people obviously disagree, with this month seeing the launch of a fans campaign to buy the club. Personally I�m not convinced this can work as I just can�t see them being able to generate enough cash.
It all sounds great on the face of it, especially when they keep referring to it as the �Barcelona Model�, but what happens if they somehow do come up with the money Ashley is wanting and buy him out?
They would then be in charge but where is the money going to come from to run the club and buy players etc?
Yes, it might be great having some fans making decisions but financially, I think we would be in a similar, if not worse, position than we are now.
Maybe if they started referring to it as the Ebbsfleet rather than the Barcelona model, people might not find it so attractive.
I think the best thing the Newcastle fans can do at the moment is support the team 110% and help get us back into the Premier League.
Owners, players and managers come and go, but no matter what stupid name they decide to call the stadium, the club will still exist and it will always be St James� Park to the supporters.
COMMENT ON THIS ARTICLE
BACK TO THE STEWART PEARSON COLUMN
INDEX
A GUARANTEED PROFIT OF AT LEAST �40.07 ON ARSENAL v CHELSEA
There's a full round of Premier League fixtures this weekend and did you know that it is possible to win money on Sunday afternoon's clash between Arsenal and Chelsea, whatever the result?
The game kicks off at 4.00pm UK Time and we can guarantee you a profit of at least �40.07, whatever the result of the match. All you have to do is follow the simple instructions below and then sit back and enjoy the game. At full-time, you will be at least �40.07 better off, whatever the result of the match.
A GUARANTEED PROFIT OF AT LEAST �40.07 ON ARSENAL v CHELSEA
Comments On This Article
Chuck, November 26, 2009 at 8:30 pm Stewart, could`nt have stated it better, you have hit the nail on the head.
However how you can possibly convert a rabid anti Asley mob to agree with our viewpoint is another thing.
Toonloony, November 26, 2009 at 8:42 pm Spot on article, I agree with pretty much all of it!! I am glad someone had the balls to put on the web what I am sure a lot of raional minded supporters are already thinking. As for the fans buyout I agree, stacks of input but not stacks of money!!!! Bloody well put!!!
Simon Lowerson, November 26, 2009 at 8:43 pm At last someone who actually agrees with me. Things would have been a lot worse if Fat Freddy was still in the hotseat, he is to blame for putting us in the financial predicament we have found ourselves in, buying over rated players on simply stupid wages. Relegation was a disaster which was long overdue and will only benefit us next season should we go straight back up.
peter, November 26, 2009 at 8:44 pm aye i agree aswell- but doubt ule ever change the anti ashley mob til we win sumit major whilst hes in charge, through his contribution- ie-putting a substantial amount in to buy in each transfer window from now onwards-that way he mite just appease the fans-its possible-fergie was nearly sacked at man u but he stayed n got it rite-long term is the key-but will he just sell to offload the problem-thus having no stabilty again?
Robby Bobson, November 26, 2009 at 9:10 pm I agree with what you say about Freddy as he didnt have the money to bail us out of the financial catrastophe that we were heading for.
However he has made too many mistakes and refuses to change or accept responsibility. His attitude is shocking...ie him and llambias chuckling away at the anti ashley chants.
I accept that money isnt going to be splashed this season, hardly any championship club will be. Also he deserves great credit for trying to improve the scouting network and getting some great youngsters into the club.
But whats with the stadium name change. Sports direct branding for 6 months without a penny coming into the club? Ridiculous and the faster he gets out the better as he is always going to be looking for a way out.
tony, November 26, 2009 at 9:11 pm I\'ll comment on this article youre an idiot, a complete and utter idiot, you shouldnt write anything about Newcastle again as you know absolutely nothing.
No sorry you are either Lliambas, a Mackem or someone who has never seen a game of football away from his TV set.
Your argument is just because Shepherd was useless it isnt all bad that Fat Mike is even more useless. Unbelievable
Shane, November 26, 2009 at 9:21 pm Maybe he will give us a bit of money since Tescos have just mistakingly payed his company �984,000 for 6 push bikes instead of �984.
doubt it tho
nomis_jade, November 26, 2009 at 9:30 pm Spot on article! i agree with everything you have said. Relagation admittedly was terrible but like you say, a blessing in disguise. IF, we go back up we will be in a much better position. My ideal scenario would be that we go back up and finally someone comes in and buys the club for the money it is worth.
Cheers buddy for a good read!
Adam, November 26, 2009 at 10:10 pm How can you love the club if you believe that rubbish you wrote? Your talking about this x amount of money. What money is that? He\'s just using this club to advertise his crap shops and having a right laugh at us. If ur a toon fan i\'m ashamed to be one
Ian, November 26, 2009 at 10:32 pm The author of this ridiculous article obviously \"gets off\" on being abused and ridiculed by rich fat businessmen. Seriously, to all you Pro Ashley wallahs, I have to ask, are you blind or simply stupid.
Ashley and llambias have done nothing but leech money from the club and take the piss out of the fans since day one. Wake up, you idiots.... :)
matt, November 26, 2009 at 10:34 pm So to sum up the good things Ashley has done are buy a few kids (two of which were on the books before he arrived) and sold the naming rights to the stadium, only he hasn�t sold them, he�s given away for nothing until the end of the season. Well done Mile, you�re a real hero.
Stewart Pearson, November 26, 2009 at 10:41 pm Cheers for the comments and interest in the article guys.
@Tony, for the record im a season ticket holder, im definitely not a Mackem or Derek Llambias!
My argument wasnt that because Shepherd was useless means that Ashley\'s poor decisions are ok. As I acknowledged Ashley has clearly made mistakes but at the end of the day we are probably in no worse position than we would have been under Shepherd, in fact id hazard a guess that we are probably in a better position than we would have been with Fat Fred.
That doesnt make Ashley a good owner by any stretch but my point was there are some positives from his tenure and due to none of us having a magic wand to go back in time then rather than dwelling on this Anti Ashley campaign maybe it would be more beneficial to get behind the team and get us back to the Premier League. If we do go up then I think most people will get their wish of a new owner, if it doesnt happen then the guy may well be around for a while longer.
Jon, November 26, 2009 at 11:03 pm So despite the fact that 99% of people hate Ashley, three of his supporters post their support to him at almost exactly the same time(8.42, 8.43 and 8.44)
shellshock, November 27, 2009 at 8:10 am Well that was a great long list of great things ashley has done wasnt it!!
There are far more commercial opportunities to explore over and above renaming the stadium, leave it alone!!
Fans buy out - fans making decisions, read and research, get some facts, if this yes we can campaign succeds it will not be the fans as you say it making decisons, it will be professionally appointed people who will answer to the fans, and the same fans who are pushing for a buy out are also saying support the team every match, get there, sing your hearts out, then join and contribute to the poistive change we need at ownership level.
Spartan, November 27, 2009 at 8:59 am How can you say Ashley has done well simply because it could have been worse under FFS. Ashley got us relegated. He brought in players like Xisco and sold players like Given and Milner. I don\'t think it could have been worse under anyone.
Stewart Pearson, November 27, 2009 at 2:35 pm @Spartan
Thanks for your interest in the article. Some people seem to have some very selective reading. As I mentioned in my above reply to Tony im not saying Ashley has done well and im not saying just because Shepherd was rubbish that makes Ashley good.
Yes some poor players have been brought in and some good ones sold but my point was that I think with Shepherd still in charge we would have ended up getting relegated at some point. Had that happened, with the financial position he had us in, a relegation under his leadership could have been catastrohic along the lines of Leeds Utd.
Of course relegation isnt good but as far as getting relegated goes we seem at the moment anyway to have got off quite lightly. We didnt lose all our star players and currently are well positioned for an instant return to the top flight with most of the overpaid stars shipped out and some promising youngsters in the team.
My main point is that I dont think things are quite as bad a people like to make out - there are clubs in much worse positions than us currently.
Just my thoughts on the matter of course, the beauty of football is everyone has an opinion.
|
|
|
|
| COLUMNISTS |
|
|
 |
|
|