| MAIN MENU |
| SPORTS NEWS |
|
|
|
| SPECIAL ARTICLES |
|
|
|
| GENERAL ARTICLES |
|
|
|
| MISCELLANEOUS |
|
|
 |
|
|
|
THE JOSHUA BARRETT COLUMN
NEWCASTLE UNITED: THE CHAMPIONSHIP�S MANCHESTER UNITED?
Joshua Barrett, 2 Mar 2010
A Tale of Two United�s
Manchester United and Newcastle United � Two teams equally disliked by the majority of ardent football fans for entirely separate reasons.
Sheer arrogance, over-confidence and an un-matched raw belief are traits I can vouch for as a Newcastle fan, and traits I can understand other football fans would snigger at.
The same could be applied to Manchester United fans, although I haven�t met that many so I best not speculate.
Column Continues Below...
A Brief History
Both these glorious clubs have a long tradition�Manchester United's stretches back to 1878 as they came to fruition under the name of Newton Heath.
Newcastle United was formed in 1892. It is quite clear Newcastle United don�t have the trophy cabinet, success or overall achievements of Manchester United�s.
However there are many factors which bring these well-supported clubs together.
Obviously both clubs are similar in the sense they both have grass on the pitch and both have white nets which are sometimes hit more than others! But here are a couple more examples:
Both Clubs Love Their Strikers
All joking aside�Manchester United have a canny knack of pinching some of St.James Park�s finest strikers.
Controversially, Andy Cole�s move back in 1995 stirred anger among Newcastle fans for selling one of their prized assets to their main rivals.
Micheal Owen arrived at Old Trafford on a free transfer at the beginning of the current season.
Thankfully Manchester United never got Owen's former England strike partner Alan Shearer.
Further back in the two club's histories, the battle between the two clubs for the then 18-year-old Wayne Rooney in 2004 was greeted with anticipation and excitement from both sides as to what they could potentially be getting their hands on.
Big Spenders In Every Sense
Championship hot-shots Newcastle United and Premier League champions Manchester United may be in an entirely different league�
But the all time Premier League table shows the two clubs are more alike than you might think.
Manchester United sit proudly in the top position with an accumulated 1409 points while Newcastle United are sat in a respectable 6th spot with 906 points.
Both clubs are more alike, as even though they may be in completely different leagues, wages from Newcastle�s perspective are still at Premier League level.
Here are a few comparisons between Newcastle United and Manchester United in terms of their players and how much they are earning per week:
Newcastle United Players: Joey Barton, Jos� Enrique, Alan Smith, Nicky Butt and Fabricio Coloccini (�60,000 a week) Jonas Gutierrez and Xisco (On Loan) (�50,000 a week) Steven Taylor, Danny Guthrie and Shola Ameobi (�40,000 a week)
Astronomical wages for such average footballers � Manchester United stars such as Micheal Carrick and Wes Brown earn around �60,000 a week. Whereas Ji-Sung Park, John O�Shea and Johnny Evans are on considerably less.
I know which players/characters I�d rather have in my dressing room on those wages.
With Manchester United just behind Chelsea by a point it would be unfair to claim Newcastle are the Manchester United of the Championship, because, technically, that would be false.
Player Comparisons�(Yes I�m being deadly serious)
A vast array of sheer mediocrity at best has swept through the dressing room door at Newcastle� Luque,Boumsong, Bramble, Babayaro, Hugo Viana, Kluivert, Geremi, Faye, Barton to name but a few.
However, relegation has forced Newcastle to re-build their squad. Chris Hughton�s emphasis on youth and talent as seen with the purchase of Danny Simpson, from Manchester United, has proved shrewd business.
Add to this � The loan captures of Patrick Van Aanholt (Looks very impressive) and Fitz Hall.
Meanwhile the permanent signings of Mike Williamson, Wayne Routledge and Leon Best have injected pace and exuberance, particularly Routledge and Best, who contributed to the free-scoring games against Cardiff, Preston and Reading.
Quite clearly the two United�s are on an entirely different platform and you may be thinking how on earth can you compare players. But there are certain Newcastle players I would take over Manchester United ones.
Manchester United opted for pace and athleticism when buying Antonia Valencia and Gabriel Obertan�the same cannot be applied to Micheal Owen.
It must also be said Manchester United have had their fair share of flops over the years - those which spring to mind include Veron, Forlan, Taibi, Djemba Djemba and Kleberson.
United v United�Player For Player
Danny Simpson v Rafael � Rafael has looked shaky at times this season (Lack of experience perhaps?) and short of confidence. However he is only young and learning his trade. Simpson should have been kept as adequate back-up to the first team. VERDICT: Rafael
Steven Taylor v Johnny Evans � Both young, both promising, both have looked unsteady at times at Premiership level. Taylor captains/captained the England Under-21�s and looked solid, whereas Evans is a full international for Northern Ireland and starts every game. VERDICT: Taylor
Jonas Gutierrez v Nani � Both show glimpses of talent from time to time, but both are very frustrating to watch. Nevertheless, Gutierrez�s debut against Man United in a 1-1 draw was one of the best debuts I�ve ever seen, although he hasn�t improved or maintained that level of form since then. VERDICT: Draw
Manchester United excel in most departments quite clearly. However Newcastle�s squad does include some promising young players such as Andy Caroll, Tim Krul and Jose Enrique.
All Eyes Upon The United�s
Both clubs are massive for differing reasons, however, the media spotlight is always hovering over St.James Park and Old Trafford.
As many of you will know, being a Newcastle fan is never boring - it's a constant soap opera filled with sub-plots and enthralling twists.
Both Clubs Hate Their Respective Owners�
Mike Ashley�s decision to rename St.James Park 'Sports direct.com @ St.James Park' is probably his most radical move so far, add to this the decision to unveil that hideous custard cream away top, an immense lack of transfer funds and just generally getting every decision wrong and you have a very unpopular owner.
While Tampa Bay Buccaneers enthusiast and owner Malcolm Glazer doesn�t exactly have the full support of the United fans.
Yellow and green scarves can be seen in the stands in protest to the owners.
The Manchester United supporters group, said: "The symbol has a power that has excited people and the momentum is happening without any need to force it.�
The financial situation at United threatens to put the club at risk with debts of around �716 Million. Newcastle�s position is not as extreme, as Ashley cleared most of the �100 Million debt from his own back pocket.
To Conclude�
We are not in 1995/1996 when Newcastle had that 12-point lead in January and let it slip to Manchester United, the gap between the clubs couldn�t be any further apart.
A once great rivalry is no longer, Philippe Albert scoring an exquisite lob over Peter Schmeichel in a 5-0 win will not happen again or at least not anytime soon.
The sheer magnitude of both clubs is what makes them familiar, an entertaining brand of football is expected by every fan, a passion and willingness to attend to every match is evident for both sets of supporters.
Just look at the attendance records�Manchester United�s highest gate was 76, 097 in 2007 against Blackburn. While Newcastle houses 52,000 week in week out.
Even having slipped down a division, Newcastle hold the record for highest attendance ever within the Championship.
Newcastle will return to the scared land in a year�s time and will battle with their old-time rival, however it may not be a happy outcome for the black and white.
Manchester United are champions for the Premiership and Newcastle United are on course to top the Championship.
COMMENT ON THIS ARTICLE
BACK TO THE JOSHUA BARRETT COLUMN
INDEX
A GUARANTEED NO-LOSE BET FROM BETCLIC
Our good friends at Betclic have offered you, our loyal readers, the best betting offer of the season so far.
It's very simple and this is how it works;
1.
Click here to open an account with Betclic.
2. Have a �20.00 bet on any sporting event you like. You can bet more if you wish, but the refund offer is for �20.00 or less.
3. If you bet wins, well done! If your bet loses, you get a �20.00 refund.
You just can't lose with this offer.
CLICK HERE TO OPEN YOUR BETCLIC ACCOUNT AND TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THIS EXCELLENT OFFER
Comments On This Article
Michael, March 2, 2010 at 6:17 pm excellent article joshua
Jamie, March 2, 2010 at 6:18 pm Utter twaddle.
Dave, March 2, 2010 at 6:22 pm Extremely good article, but i still think man u slightly have the edge lol
Matthew Brown, March 2, 2010 at 6:28 pm Good article as ever mate with some interesting comparisons. Not sure if Newcastle are disliked by the majority to the same extent Man Utd are! Personally I would say Newc fans alienate many other supporters with some of the high expectations and the OTT welcomes given to Owen and Keegan etc, when the rest of the nation knew what was going to happen! Although many were happy to see Newc go down I dont think was a personal thing, it was just the demise of a big club. However I\'m sure if you went back to these supporters (including myself), they would much rather see Newcastle in PL than Burnely or Hull. Even the universally hated Leeds United I\'m sure would be welcomed back into the Premier League by the majority! We want the biggest teams in the biggest leagues. It is much more fun playing and hopefully beating Leeds or Newcastle than with the greatest respect, Wolves (from a Chelsea fans view).
Finally, Jonny Evans is literally leagues above Steven Taylor. Vidic and Ferdinand have barely played together this season, and Evans slots in perfectly. Not sure if Taylor would slot into the Man U team so easily, although would be good to see him getting regular Prem League football again, with or without the Toon.
Good article mate
Mr W Guthrie, March 2, 2010 at 6:50 pm Excellent article, Joshua.
richietoon, March 2, 2010 at 7:21 pm wheres this knack of pinching our finest strikers????..........they\'ve had one,Andy Cole
lameduck, March 2, 2010 at 7:23 pm Isn\'t cheap lager great ? A couple of cans and a keyboard and you can while away a few hours and come up with this - well done mate, just be careful not to spill on the laptop
Joe, March 2, 2010 at 7:28 pm Danny Guthrie ia on 4 grand a week, not 40!!!!! His payslip was in the paper!!!!! That does however make him a snip!!!!!
Kenzen, March 2, 2010 at 8:05 pm
Very sloppy. Could do better ...
\"A once great rivalry is no longer, Philippe Albert scoring an exquisite lob over Peter Schmeichel in a 5-0 win will not happen again or at least not anytime soon.\"
Probably not, seeing as both players have hung up their boots, so OK I\'ll give you that.
\"Just look at the attendance records�Manchester United�s highest gate was 76,097 in 2007 against Blackburn. While Newcastle houses 52,000 week in week out.\"
Week in, week out? What are 52,000 people doing at SJP when Toon are playing away? We may have had 50-52,00 in the Prem, but in the Fizzy Pop it\'s more like 35-45,00. But only when the Toon are playing ...
\"Newcastle will return to the scared land in a year�s time ....\"
So if we win the Fizzy Pop this season, we won\'t be admitted to the \'scared\' [sic] land until March 2011????
Sloppy ...
Tom, March 3, 2010 at 1:29 pm The two clubs are nothing alike. One competes in the Champions league year in year out, the other would be happy with the intertoto every 5. One has had 1 manager in 25 years the other... well i say no more. Success?? Complete nonsense mate
smoggy, March 3, 2010 at 1:35 pm Why does everyone keep saying Newcastle are a \"BIG CLUB\"???
They are only big in the sense of they have a big ground, which I hasten to add, is not full \'week in week out\' so wake up, your \'big time\' has been & gone
stuart, March 3, 2010 at 1:52 pm Oh dear, typical geordie, comparing themselves to Man Utd!!!laughable. only one comparison- both sets of fans hate their owners, apart from that none what so ever. Yes you probably get the highest crowds in the championship-but only because you have the biggest ground! Man Utd win on every aspect against Newcastle-no contest
|
|
|
|
| COLUMNISTS |
|
|
 |
|
|