| MAIN MENU |
| SPORTS NEWS |
|
|
|
| DAILY ARTICLES |
|
|
|
| WEEKLY ARTICLES |
|
|
|
| GENERAL ARTICLES |
|
|
|
| MISCELLANEOUS |
|
|
 |
|
|
|
LEAGUE OF INJUSTICE - WEEK ONE - TOTTENHAM HOTSPUR v LIVERPOOL
Jeff Winter, 17 Aug 2009
PLEASE SEE THE LEAGUE OF INJUSTICE RULES BEFORE COMMENTING
CLICK HERE FOR THE REVISED TABLE
The opening weekend of the Premier League was a relatively quiet one, without too much controversy.
Indeed, from the games I watched and the highlights I saw, it appeared that this article was going to be a blank page for the first ever time.
Then the final game - Tottenham Hotspur v Liverpool - threw up some talking points.
Article Continues Below...
One penalty was given and two appeals were turned down.
I don�t think anyone, even the most biased Spurs supporter, could argue against the penalty for another rush of blood from Gomez, who needlessly brought down Liverpool�s Glen Johnson.
The other two appeals were not so clear cut.
In no way did I think that the �hand-ball� warranted a spot kick. The defender did not move his hand or arm towards the ball and it was driven towards him from a short distance at pace and hit him with his arm across his chest.
The second shout was more debatable. Whilst the ball was probably going to go to the keeper anyway, it cannot be disputed that the Spurs defender did make contact with the Liverpool attacker Voronin and a penalty should have been awarded.
Ironically, I thought Spurs were good value for all three points, but the penalty makes it 2-2 and our first and only correction of the opening weekend.
Verdict: 2-2 instead of 2-1 to Spurs.
CLICK HERE FOR THE REVISED TABLE
CHECK OUT JEFF WINTER'S OFFICIAL WEBSITE BY CLICKING HERE
PLEASE SEE THE LEAGUE OF INJUSTICE RULES BEFORE COMMENTING
COMMENT ON THIS ARTICLE
BACK TO LEAGUE OF INJUSTICE INDEX
A GUARANTEED PROFIT OF AT LEAST �48.46 ON RAPID VIENNA v ASTON VILLA
The Europa League kicks off it's debut season this week and did you know that it is possible to win money on Thursday evening's clash between Aston Villa and Rapid Vienna, whatever the result?
The game kicks off at 6.15pm UK Time and we can guarantee you a profit of at least �48.46, whatever the result of the match. All you have to do is follow the simple instructions below and then sit back and enjoy the game. At full-time, you will be at least �48.46 better off, whatever the result of the match.
CLICK HERE FOR A GUARANTEED PROFIT OF AT LEAST �48.46 ON RAPID VIENNA v ASTON VILLA
Comments On This Article
Sagar, August 10, 2009 at 5:04 pm yup,
hes dug a hole for himself.
But, this gives the FA/Premier League/Refs association a chance to sort this issue out once and for all before the season starts and these sort of decisions really start to matter!!
baby blue, August 10, 2009 at 5:37 pm I would not let Evra himself off scott free. he was checked by Ballack of that there is no doubt. But he went down holding his face which was patently NOT the contact point. He was trying to get Ballack in trouble. This is probably why the referee did not stop the game to allow treatment - he didn\'t need treatment.
But Evra (like many others Drogba more than most) stayed down, not helping his team and kept up the pretence. If he had not tried to make a meal of the situation, and advantage had been played then no-one would be talking today.
Note also the number of ManU players surrounding, pushing and barging the referee. No mention of that in any of the media. One rule for them......
Maka, August 10, 2009 at 5:47 pm Whats up Jeff? No mention of United players crowding the ref? Oh wait, we are only supposed to complain about that when it involves Chelsea. You used the entire 08 season to have a go at Chelsea when they crowded the ref. Yesterday United did it AGAIN, and you sit silent. Surprising? No.
Isaidso, August 10, 2009 at 6:12 pm There\'s surrounding the referee, and then surrounding the referee in the LUNATIC way with murderous intent that Chelsea players did, and were rightfully banned for several CL games. United players weren\'t out of control, and were right to approach Foy as the player was on the ground too long. I watched the Video incident, and Ballack DID hit both chest and side of face because his arm kept flailing upwards. Ballack admtted the foul and acknowledge the ref should have stopped play.
Jeff is right in his assessment, no advantage, then play has to be brought back, free kick awarded, and card shown. But then Jeff was a ref who never shirked the hard decisions - one of the few ref\'s to do so I might add. Well said Jeff, and your right of course.
KD, August 10, 2009 at 6:42 pm Lunatic and murderous intent? Hahaha. Oh my, you got to love these mancs with their red tinted glasses. Hilarious stuff.
Maka is right. United players are a complete disgrace, they should be banned for at least 5+ games. Evra got what he deserved. Falling around crying like a little girl, didnt work this time, did it you little cheating manc?
pjch, August 10, 2009 at 7:56 pm Interesting to read all the comments made so far
Was it a foul by Ballack. Yes. Even he admitted it himself. Should Foy have blown for a free kick. Yes. If he had done his job properly than all the stories and discussions would not have happened since the end of the match
ManU, August 10, 2009 at 8:43 pm The refree spoil the game and should be suspended by FIFA.Next was Ballack all out to avenge against Evera long term comflict.First Ballack play acting caused Evera a yellow card which was obviously a good tackle.Then came the bad tackle which the refree should yellow carded Ballack but closed his eyes when foul was commited infront of him.The equaliser goal should not stand because Drogba clearly foul Ben Foster to allow Carvelo to score and we have seen other refree have given a free kick against Drogba but Foy chosed to close his eyes.
Brett cfc, August 10, 2009 at 10:09 pm When Carrick was put in position to put through a chip pass to the strikers, was that not receiving advantage? The ball had moved through two players.
How can you decide after TWO passes that there\'s no advantage after all?
If you get to that, then you might as well pull it up after two minutes or when there\'s a turnover in possession after 90 seconds and the team didn\'t score - and that\'s not how football is refereed. (Unlike rugby.)
Evra simulated that he was hit in the head, rolled around with his hands on his face, no wonder Foy didn\'t whistle.
Carrick saw Evra rolling on the ground, and played the lofted pass anyway, after receiving it from Rooney.
Why should Chelsea kick it out if Utd didn\'t, and why should the referee stop play if Utd were happy to take advantage of getting back the ball?
Nonsense.
Wozza, August 17, 2009 at 5:18 pm \"The second shout was more debatable. Whilst the ball was probably going to go to the keeper anyway, it cannot be disputed that the Spurs defender did make contact with the Liverpool attacker Voronin and a penalty should have been awarded.\"
Sorry Jeff, but the Spurs defender didn\'t push Voronin, he didn\'t trip him, he didn\'t obstruct him. The ball was running away from Voronin anyway to the point where he wasn\'t even going to make contact and as for the \'contact\' it was the Spurs defender going shoulder to shoulder and giving more than Voronin did. It\'s the sort of thing you see a thousand times every weekend and no, it wasn\'t a penalty. As for your \'revised\' result, ironically the Voronin incident, the handball and the Gomes tackle on Johnson were some of the few decisions that Phil Dowd got right during the match. Liverpool should have had one red card for numerous yellow card fouls by the same player (Kuyt) yet they mostly went unpunished. Against 10 men, Spurs would have had even more of the play than they did against 11, and would have likely scored again, so actually the \'revised\' result was 3-1. Of course that is just my opinion and doesn\'t make it fact. Just like yours...
What is a fact is that Liverpool didn\'t bring their best game to WHL and were punished for it, regardless of the penalty incidents, and Spurs got the 3 points that they deserved. You and Benitez can point out the inaccuracies of the referee\'s decisions, but he made those decisions in the flow of the game and I would bet money that he sees no reason to change his view in hindsight. COYS!!!
Stratty, August 17, 2009 at 5:18 pm NO IDEA WHAT CHELSEA AND MAN U FANS ARE DOING COMMENTING ON THIS ARTICLE.
SHOULDNT HAVE BEEN 2-2 BECAUSE YOU HAVE TO SCORE THE PENALTY. BESIDES WHICH, WE HAD A PENALTY SHOUT BEFORE VERONIN\'S, SO WE\'LL HAVE A GOAL OURSELVES, AND THAT\'LL BE 3-2.
UNITED LOOKED PEDESTRIAN APART FROM ROONEY, BUT THEN THEY ALWAYS DO THIS TIME OF YEAR.
CITY LOOKED IMMEDIATELY DANGEROUS. UNLIKE CHELSEA, YEARS AGO, THEY HAVE BOUGHT PLAYERS WITH PREM EXPERIENCE, SO EXPECT QUICKER RESULTS.
CHELSEA LOOKED GENUINE CHAMPIONS-ELECT.
LIVERPOOL LOOKED WEAK - BUT THEN IT WAS MOSTLY THE DETERMINATION TO STOP UNITED THAT PROPELLED LAST YEAR. HAVING FAILED, THEY WON\'T BE AS STRONG THIS CAMPAIGN.
Adzi, August 17, 2009 at 5:26 pm 2-1 Actually, a penalty is never a dead cert to be scored although its more likely they\'d score than miss, i say gerrard put the 2nd penalty in the stand. Lol good value as always Jeff
Ol\'Git, August 17, 2009 at 5:27 pm First penalty no arguments nailed on.
Handball. We all agree no pen.
The other one for which you say a penalty should have been awarded, I\'m not so sure. It was a shoulder to shoulder challenge which surprisingly is still legal. In any case there was no guarantee the penalty would have been scored so it is double conjecture. So I say you should stick with the result which was 2-1.
Raj Randash, August 17, 2009 at 5:40 pm what a load of bollox, shoulder charge is not an offence.
BristolBlue, August 17, 2009 at 5:45 pm The challenge from Gomes was a clear penalty, going away from goal so no red card.
Shoulder contact is allowable still in the game and Voronin never had control of the ball. It would have been a travisty, especially as no-one has mentioned the blatant push in Crouch\'s back in the Liverpool area in the run up to that incident.
Rafa should look at his own performance rather than the refs and his midfield. His failure to replace last season\'s best player, who was sorely missed, left a gaping hole. Tactically Harry did \'im and Rafa failed to respond. Liverpool did not look like they could score in open play if they played till midnight.
In the words of Ricky Tomlinson;
\"Title contenders, my arse!\"
oldun, August 17, 2009 at 5:50 pm Two points to make.
Its a question of interpretation by the referee and his officials of what THEY see.
Secondly if the referee has ANY doubt they shouldn\'t give it.
Thanks goodness Winter is only exercising his inflated ego and isn\'t still refereeing.
When was a shoulder to shoulder challenged illegal? Seems that Winter like Benitez wants to make it a non-contact sport for the girls. Given the respective size of Assou Ekotto and Voronin the red collapsed as if he been tackled by Palacios. Big girl\'s blouse.
Balanced Opinion, August 17, 2009 at 5:53 pm YES All top 3 teams + Macherano harass referees in a way that is unacceptable and would not be allowed in rugby.
Managers fail to control players and lie about incidents they can\'t defend. Instead of publicly admonishing them for unacceptable behaviour.
Drogba should have been banned for 8 games for his behaviour, not just a couple of meaningless qualifiers. Plus fined 2 weeks wages to be given to charity.
Kids watch these antics and copy them. Be it Ronaldo flicks, Rooney\'s persistent \"F Off ref\" or Drogba\'s diving and all 4 of the teams surrounding the ref.
I hope that Man City, Villa, Everton and Spurs occupy the top 4 places and teach these spoilt brats a lesson.
Fatfish, August 17, 2009 at 5:58 pm I\'m getting fed up with the focus on the 2 penalties that Liverpool didn\'t get. What about the 2 that Spurs didn\'t get.
There was a handball by Kuyt, similar circumstances to Ekotto\'s and then the blatant push on Crouch by Carragher.
Lightning Smith, August 17, 2009 at 6:14 pm It happens at every corner.
Get real Mr winter it was a good old fashioned bump at best,
MJ, August 17, 2009 at 7:10 pm What a silly article, If every penalty decision equated to a goal there would be 4 world cup stars on Englands shirt and a couple of European trophies in the cabinet too! go find something useful to write about coys!!!!!!!
FACTS, August 17, 2009 at 7:31 pm Obviously not a goal scoring opportunity and intent to foul not there
Verdict
2-1 to Spurs and a 6 month touchline ban on Benitez/Lee for repeatedly bringing the game into disrepute
JimB, August 17, 2009 at 7:56 pm Actually, Jeff, as others have pointed out, it shouldn\'t have been 2-2 to Liverpool at all. It should actually have been 3-1 to Spurs.
Exactly 15 seconds before Assou Ekotto went shoulder to shoulder with Voronin, Jamie Carragher barged into the back of Peter Crouch as the Spurs striker was in mid air and trying to head an incoming Jamie O\'Hara free kick towards Pepe Reina\'s goal. Carragher made not the slightest attempt to play the ball. He just deliberatly nudged Crouch out of the path of the ball.
It was a clear foul, two yards inside the Liverpool penalty area. And this wasn\'t one of those instances when there was a massive crowd of players and no chance for the ref to see what had happened. Crouch was the only Spurs player in the penalty area and he and Carragher were completely on their own. Phil Dowd had a completely unobstructed view. It was as blatant as you like and Dowd bottled it.
If he had made the right decision, at the very time that Voronin was appealing for a penalty, Jermain Defoe would have been placing the ball on the Liverpool penalty spot. The Assou Ekotto shoulder barge would never have occured. Thankfully, Dowd refused Voronin\'s penalty claims. Otherwise it would have been doubly unjust.
So 2-1 to Tottenham should be 3-1 to Tottenham.
That\'s all.
keith, August 17, 2009 at 8:16 pm what about the handball down the other end [dsecond half]
Chirpy, August 17, 2009 at 8:25 pm Rather than a penalty for Liverpool, Spurs had a good shout for a freekick on the edge of the Liverpool box prior to the passage of play that saw Assou-Ekoto collide with Voronin. I would implore Snr Benetiz to watch the replay and see the deliberate shove in Peter Crouch\'s back that saw Spurs lose possession. Glass houses and stones come to mind. Chirpy
Confussed, August 17, 2009 at 8:26 pm Can I say before I ask the the question that I am not \"moaning or complaining\", I am just trying to get an understanding of the offside rule.
When Spurs scored their first goal, there was a Spurs player in an offside position standing a short distance from Liverpools keeper and the ball came close to the Spurs player.
In similar situations last season managers and pundits said that the player in offside had to be interfering with play because there was a possibility off the keeper being unsighted by the player.
My question is when is a player interfering with play.
As I said earlier I am trying to understand and any comments would be appreciated.
PS Liverpool were very poor and Spurs deserved the win.
JimB, August 17, 2009 at 8:43 pm Chirpy - have another look. Spurs shouldn\'t have had a free kick on the edge of the Liverpool box just prior to Voronin\'s penalty appeal.......
Spurs should have had a PENALTY! Carragher\'s foul on Crouch was two yards inside Liverpool\'s penalty area.
Confused - I think you have a point about Defoe. The ref or linesman could well have interpreted that Defoe was obstructing Reina\'s view of the ball from an offside position. However, it would have been a very harsh call since, even if Reina had had a perfect view of the ball, there is no way in the world that he would have been able to make the save. Common sense prevailed. It would be a crying shame if such a marvellous goal had been disallowed on a technicality.
MikeH, August 17, 2009 at 10:11 pm Jeff,
you suggested the decision was debatable, which judging by the responses, has been debated, I personally can\'t see any which way this is a penalty, contact, as you put it is not an offence, where was the foul, if this was in the centre of the park would you give a free kick? Jeff go consult your linesman - you need one on this blog| BTW Did you see the Palace game, even you might have got that one right!
Colman McG, August 18, 2009 at 11:10 am For all the spurs fans well done and no one is denying you deserved the three points on the balance of play, but please take your head out of the sand. For one it never should of been a free kick for your second goal, and as for voronins penalty appeal if you remember correctly not about ten minutes earlier Ekotto had been challenged for a ball just outside the box running parallel to the goal line and went shoulder to shoulder and he went down, ref gives a free out. Now all any player wants is consistant refs, as Andy Gray put it in commentary if what happened, happened outside the box the ref is giving a free every single time. This is not sour grapes, as I said you played by far the better football, but ignorance is bliss, nothing worse than a sore and blind winner.
Noblelox, August 18, 2009 at 1:20 pm The hand ball was a pen, because it bounced off is right arm in front of his chest, and then hit it left arm which was out at his side, and it is the contact with his left arm that deflected the ball away from goal, and it was far enough away from his body to be given. The Veronin one was also a cert, and the comment above saying shoulder charges are not illegal is bolloocks in itself, as it is illegal. But as a Liverpool supporter, the result was correct on the day, we did not deserve anything from the game, but often the luck of prospective champons is that they get 3 points when often they deserve none. Botom line the ref bottled it and didn\'t have the nerve to award multiple penalties to an away team.
JimB, August 18, 2009 at 1:47 pm @ Colman McG and Noblelox...
Sorry, lads, but I can\'t allow your posts to pass without response.
Never a free kick for Spurs\' second goal? I suggest that you take another look. Jamie Carragher clearly realised that Jermain Defoe had stolen a march on him and so he thrust his arm out into Defoe\'s face / chest in order to obstruct the Spurs player. Watch the replays. It\'s a clear as the glorious daylight that afternoon. If any further proof that the ref made the correct decision was needed (and it isn\'t), you only have to look at Carragher\'s reaction to the free kick award and the yellow card. There wasn\'t even a murmur of complaint. He knew what he had done (a professional foul to help his team) and he accepted the punishment as a fair exchange.
As to the Ekotto foul on Voronin, I repeat: that foul would never have happened if Dowd had rightly awarded a penalty to Spurs 15 seconds earlier, when Carragher clearly fouled Peter Crouch in Liverpool\'s penalty area. So, yes, the ref did \"bottle it\" but it is Spurs who should be complaining.
Finally, as to the handball, you do understand that arms and hands are attached to the body, don\'t you? There is only so much that players can do to avoid the ball hitting their arms or hands while also trying to run, jump or turn. In this case, the ball was kicked AT Ekotto from a distance of less than five yards. He had no time to react. The ball hit his right hand (not vice versa) as it was in front of his chest. It then ricocheted and changed direction dramatically down towards the ground and hit his other hand in the process. As with his right hand, Ekotto could never have done anything to stop the ricochet hitting his left hand. He doesn\'t, unfortunately (and like every other member of the human race) have the reaction speed of the Six Million Dollar Man. In both cases, contact was BALL TO HAND. And in neither case was the player trying to gain an advantage. So the ref was quite correct to wave away all penalty appeals.
It would have been equally nonsensical if the ref had awarded a penalty to Spurs a few minutes earlier when Kuyt handled a ball in the Liverpool penalty area when it was blasted at him from short range.
Colman McG, August 18, 2009 at 2:35 pm JimB, relax the old cackarooneys there, before you give yourself a heartattack. At least you accepted the honest opinion of the fact you deserved the points well. But noone is doubting the handballs, anyone claiming for those handballs are grasping at straws, the voronin challenge(and that\'s what it was a challenge) is a definite penalty, how can ekotto challenge the man yet not even attempt to get the ball, that in anyones terms is a foul. Plain and simple, it\'s as simple as the challenge on defoe, Carragher put his arm across him contact was made and he went down, yes you claim it was a free but where is the line then, you want your cake and too eat it.
JimB, August 18, 2009 at 3:24 pm Colman - I\'m perfectly relaxed, thanks. I hope you are too.
I repeat - the Ekotto shoulder charge on Voronin is irrelevant. Yes, taken in isolation, I would agree that it was a foul and a penalty should have been awarded (I\'ve never denied it - so I\'ve yet to eat my cake!). But you can\'t take any incident in isolation. In this case, you have to consider what immediately preceded the Voronin penalty appeal.
Exactly 15 seconds earlier, Jamie Carragher clearly fouled Peter Crouch in the Liverpool penalty area. The ref - who had an entirely unobstructed view - should have blown for a penalty to Spurs. And if he had, the Voronin / Ekotto incident would never have occurred because Jermain Defoe would have been preparing to place the ball on the Liverpool penalty spot at that very moment.
So, really, there is no point banging on about the Voronin penalty claim.
P.S. The stuff about the handball claim was directed at Nobleox.
LIVERPOOL FAN, August 18, 2009 at 3:47 pm This thread is really stupid...reds lost and looked bad, dont need excuses...and have to bounce back before we loose ground and start complaining at the end of the season. Benitez future doesnt look so bright now
|
|
|
|
| COLUMNISTS |
|
|
 |
|
|