| MAIN MENU |
| SPORTS NEWS |
|
|
|
| DAILY ARTICLES |
|
|
|
| WEEKLY ARTICLES |
|
|
|
| GENERAL ARTICLES |
|
|
|
| MISCELLANEOUS |
|
|
 |
|
|
|
LEAGUE OF INJUSTICE - WEEK ONE - TOTTENHAM HOTSPUR v LIVERPOOL: YOUR RESPONSES
Jeff Winter, 19 Aug 2009
PLEASE SEE THE LEAGUE OF INJUSTICE RULES BEFORE COMMENTING
CLICK HERE FOR THE REVISED TABLE
The replies from my first League of Injustice article mainly fall into two categories this week.
Funnily enough, if my
opinion goes against a team, which it is bound to do, then that team's
supporters are the most vociferous.
Some have quite rightly pointed out that
a penalty does not mean a certain goal.
I know that, but if you look at the
rules for this article, you will see that the point is
covered. This is not an exact science, but a bit of fun.
************************
From: Adzi
Actually, a penalty is never a dead cert to be scored, although
it's more likely they'd score than miss.
I say Gerrard would have put the second penalty in
the stand.
Lol good value as always, Jeff.
************************
From: Alan Cheek
Hang on a minute, are we to presume that a goal is given every time
a penalty is awarded?
I can't believe a referee would come to that
assumption.
I thought it was a 50/50 one but I think the referee, Mr. Dowd,
may have been unsighted.
Jeff's reply
So hopefully having read the rules of LOI, those comments will have been
addressed.
************************
Article Continues Below...
************************
The second main point is to whether or not the challenge on Voronin was
illegal:
************************
From: Wozza
"The second shout was more debatable. Whilst the ball was probably
going to go to the keeper anyway, it cannot be disputed that the Spurs
defender did make contact with the Liverpool attacker Voronin and a penalty
should have been awarded."
Sorry Jeff, but the Spurs defender didn't push Voronin, he didn't trip him,
he didn't obstruct him.
The ball was running away from Voronin anyway, to
the point where he wasn't even going to make contact.
And as for the
'contact' itself, it was the Spurs defender going shoulder to shoulder and giving
more than Voronin did.
It's the sort of thing you see a thousand times every
weekend and no, it wasn't a penalty.
As for your 'revised' result, ironically the Voronin incident, the handball and the Gomes tackle
on Johnson, were some of the few decisions that Phil Dowd got right during
the match.
Liverpool should have had one red card for numerous yellow card
fouls by the same player (Kuyt) yet they mostly went unpunished.
Against 10 men, Spurs would have had even more of the play than they did
against 11, and would have likely scored again. So actually the 'revised'
result was 3-1.
Of course that is just my opinion and doesn't make it fact.
Just like yours...
What is a fact is that Liverpool didn't bring their best game to WHL and
were punished for it. Regardless of the penalty incidents, Spurs got the
three points that they deserved.
You and Benitez can point out the inaccuracies
of the referee's decisions, but he made those decisions in the flow of the
game and I would bet money that he sees no reason to change his view in
hindsight. COYS!!!
Jeff's reply
I agree, Spurs were the better side and deserved to win. However, I am
sticking to my guns - the defender played the man, not the ball, and that is a
foul, honestly!!
************************
From: Ol'Git
First penalty. No arguments nailed on.
Handball. We all agree, no pen.
The other one, for which you say a penalty should have been awarded, I'm not
so sure.
It was a shoulder to shoulder challenge which surprisingly is still
legal.
In any case, there was no guarantee the penalty would have been scored
so it is double conjecture. So I say you should stick with the result, which
was 2-1.
Jeff's reply
Well two out of three ain't bad!!! Our disagreement is regarding
your interpretation of the "shoulder charge" which I read as a barge from a
defender who had no intention of going for the ball. Anyway 2-1 was a fair
result.
************************
From: Raj Randash
What a load of bollox, shoulder charge is not an offence.
Jeff's reply
What an eloquent way of putting your opinion forward, albeit
incorrectly in my opinion. Pity you do not have the balls to use a real
email address!!
************************
From: BristolBlue
The challenge from Gomes was a clear penalty. He was going away from goal
so no red card.
Shoulder contact is still allowed in the game and Voronin never had
control of the ball. It would have been a travesty, especially as no-one has
mentioned the blatant push in Crouch's back in the Liverpool area in the run
up to that incident.
Rafa should look at his own performance rather than the refs, and that of his
midfield.
His failure to replace last season's best player, who was sorely
missed, left a gaping hole.
Tactically, Harry did him and Rafa failed to
respond. Liverpool did not look like they could score in open play if they
played till midnight.
In the words of Ricky Tomlinson:
"Title contenders, my arse!"
Jeff's reply
I have got to agree, Liverpool did not look good. There's a long way
to go though.
************************
From: oldun
Two points to make.
It's a question of interpretation by the referee and his officials of what
THEY see.
Secondly if the referee has ANY doubt, they shouldn't give it.
Thanks goodness Winter is only exercising his inflated ego and isn't still
refereeing.
When was a shoulder to shoulder challenge illegal? Seems that Winter, like
Benitez, wants to make it a non-contact sport for the girls.
Given the
respective size of Assou Ekotto and Voronin, the Red collapsed as if he had
been tackled by Palacios. Big girl's blouse.
Jeff's reply
Thanks for the opening sentence, just remember that next time a
decision is given against your side!!!
Size, shape etc has nothing to do
with it, a foul is a foul.
Having a qualified opinion that is different to
yours does not mean I have an inflated opinion, just a point of view, to
which, like your good self, I am entitled.
My opinion though is qualified and
unbiased and the more I watch the challenge on Voronin, the more obvious the
foul looks. It is not a shoulder charge, he actually barges him in the back.
There were other posts of a similar nature. Thanks for your opinions but I
think I have given my views on this now. Let's agree to disagree.
CLICK HERE FOR THE REVISED TABLE
CHECK OUT JEFF WINTER'S OFFICIAL WEBSITE BY CLICKING HERE
PLEASE SEE THE LEAGUE OF INJUSTICE RULES BEFORE COMMENTING
COMMENT ON THIS ARTICLE
BACK TO LEAGUE OF INJUSTICE INDEX
A GUARANTEED PROFIT OF AT LEAST �57.13 ON HULL CITY v BOLTON WANDERERS
The Premier League season continues this weekend and did you know that it is possible to win money on Saturday afternoon's clash between Hull City and Bolton Wanderers, whatever the result?
The game kicks off at 3.00pm UK Time and we can guarantee you a profit of at least �57.13, whatever the result of the match. All you have to do is follow the simple instructions below and then sit back and enjoy the game. At full-time, you will be at least �57.13 better off, whatever the result of the match.
CLICK HERE FOR A GUARANTEED PROFIT OF AT LEAST �57.13 ON HULL CITY v BOLTON WANDERERS
Comments On This Article
fergal, August 12, 2009 at 3:19 pm In response to \"Isaidso, in response to Maka\", Jeff never shirked the hard decision?
How come Dennis Wise was still on the pitch with 5 mins to go (so that he could sub himself to get a cheer from Millwall fans) in the FA Cup Final of 2004? How come Paul Scholes didn\'t get a penalty in the same game?
eoo_net, August 12, 2009 at 3:55 pm From eoo_net
In response to Maka!
Did you talk about crowding the ref? Can Maka let the people know what could have happened if Wayne Rooney, or any United player ever snatched the ref\'s red card? Jokes aside, the refs are blatantly biased against Man United. Shame on them United took the title last year. As you can see they are bent on stopping ManU this year, otherwise you would have nothing to discuss, shear jealousy.
Chelsea, August 12, 2009 at 4:54 pm Hey, I don\'t understand what the fuss is about yes it was a free kick and the ref game advantage and united took it and lost the ball. Its their own fault, if ManU thought that their player was really hurt they would have stopped the ball. Also how come nobody mentions anything about Rooner scoring the 2nd goal from an offside position. Ooooh I know cause that would go agains ManU. NOW SHUT THE Fxck UP.
daddyblue, August 12, 2009 at 8:52 pm But Roney was offside goal should not have been allowed
Parklane, August 19, 2009 at 2:27 pm I think the Assou Ekotto challenge was fair.He just muscled him off it the same way you see players do when they are seeing the ball out for a goal kick or when players just shift people off or under the ball from corners etc.All the same though I\'ve seen them given and would prob want a pen if it was other way around.Nothing should detract from the fact that Spurs deservedly won the game though so it ended with the right result imo !
meesterlee, August 19, 2009 at 2:29 pm Forget the Liverpool penalty claims, only one of which seemed indisputable. What about Carragher\'s clear push on Crouch in the area? Surely this was more of a stonewall penalty than the Voronin barge?
HarryHosk, August 19, 2009 at 3:07 pm Come on Jeff - in your opinion was that a foul on Crouch 15 seconds before the push on Voronin - or didn\'t you watch the game?
John Holmes, August 19, 2009 at 4:02 pm Re; Voronin debate - it\'s what we used to call on the streets of the East End a \'fair barge!\' If a Liverpool player had done the same to a Spurs player Andy - Top4 Brownnose-Gray would have been drooling about the way he had \'just guided\' the attacker away from goal.
Re: Push on Crouch - blatant and nailed on! Did Rafa have Arsene\'s goggles on for that one?
Rafa\'s team were second best all over the park, and they got off light at 2-1. \'Pool looked utter pants without Alonso\'s guile - Rafa has screwed up by flogging him, and like a child who knows he\'s done wrong he is chucking his toys about and blaming everyone but himself.
And eeo-net - refs biased against Man yoo?????? What a memory! Howard Webb was Man-of-the-Match against Spurs!
|
|
|
|
| COLUMNISTS |
|
|
 |
|
|