MAIN MENU
   SPORTS NEWS
   SPECIAL ARTICLES
   GENERAL ARTICLES
   MISCELLANEOUS


LEAGUE OF INJUSTICE - ARTICLE SEVEN: ARSENAL v BLACKBURN ROVERS: YOUR RESPONSES III
Jeff Winter, 14 Oct 2009

PLEASE SEE THE LEAGUE OF INJUSTICE RULES BEFORE COMMENTING

CLICK HERE FOR THE REVISED TABLE

Bookmark and Share

My League Of Injustice article on the Arsenal v Blackburn Rovers match is still provoking comment from those who think I am anti-Arsenal.

Here are the latest...

************************

From: Dan

Dear Mr Winter

I like this response thing you do. It is nice to hear what you have to say in response to comments. You can give a greater insight into how you (and perhaps other refs) see things.

I am disappointed, however, that you did not reply to a comment I made about an article you wrote about Eduardo being a blatant cheat etc.

I was hoping to read what you were thinking after you read that comment.

Oh well, I suppose.

I have to assume that perhaps you did not because it was too challenging?

Kind regards

Dan

Jeff's reply

Sorry if I missed your earlier email.

I do not recall calling Eduardo a blatant cheat, I just stated that in the Celtic game, I believed that he dived.

Regrettably, a player only has to commit one misdemeanor and he will be castigated by opposing supporters forever more.

Best wishes

Jeff

************************

Column Continues Below...



************************

From: banduan

As an Arse fan, I have to say that Jeff has been fairly even-handed so far. He's missed some points (Gallas shoulda got a peno vs Blackburn) but we all do.

Jeff's reply

See, I knew that out in the world there are some fair-minded fans!!!

Best Wishes

Jeff

************************

From: Nick I'd hate to see what these Arsenal fans would be like if you reversed a result against them. Jeff only changed the score by one goal, you still won and you still moan.

Try having two minutes of highlights every week on MotD to base decisions on every week, unlike the half hour each of the Big Four get.

Jeff's reply

I learnt a long time ago that most fans only want to see things in their club's favour. As you rightly say, I can only comment on what is shown on TV.

Best Wishes

Jeff

CLICK HERE FOR THE REVISED TABLE

CHECK OUT JEFF WINTER'S OFFICIAL WEBSITE BY CLICKING HERE

PLEASE SEE THE LEAGUE OF INJUSTICE RULES BEFORE COMMENTING

HAVE YOU GOT WHAT IT TAKES TO BE THE LAST MAN STANDING?

Bookmark and Share

COMMENT ON THIS ARTICLE

SEND THIS TO A FRIEND
BACK TO LEAGUE OF INJUSTICE INDEX
A GUARANTEED PROFIT OF AT LEAST �33.84 ON STOKE v WEST HAM

There's a full round of Premier League matches this midweek and did you know that it is possible to win money on Saturday afternoon's clash between Stoke and West Ham, whatever the result?

The game kicks off at 3.00pm UK Time and we can guarantee you a profit of at least �33.84, whatever the result of the match. All you have to do is follow the simple instructions below and then sit back and enjoy the game. At full-time, you will be at least �33.84 better off, whatever the result of the match.

A GUARANTEED PROFIT OF AT LEAST �33.84 ON STOKE v WEST HAM

Comments On This Article

gigbrin, September 22, 2009 at 4:42 pm
someone has to point out to Jeff that it\'s Uefa...not eufa..


Bergkampisgod, September 22, 2009 at 4:43 pm
The reason UEFA backed down is Eduardo was caught on the ankle. Sky pictures and even ITV pictures prove it, so it wasn\'t a \"dive\" it wasn\'t a penalty either but it wasn\'t a \"dive\". And as a former referee I would have thought you would know there doesn\'t have to be contact for there to be a foul.


mark, September 22, 2009 at 4:45 pm
I think you are forgetting Tevez did chose to go

SAF offered him a contract, he turned it down for more money at city

plus he has never stopped bad mouthing SAF and the club in the press


Ole Gunner, September 22, 2009 at 4:51 pm
Look, you\'re going on with this Eduardo nonsense. Ashley Young dived twice to win 2 penalties the night after the Eduardo incident. Most Arsenal fans say Eduardo dived. Even Wenger says Eduardo \"made the most of it\".

But your claim that a clampdown had to start somewhere is rubbished by the fact that another player dived the following night in European competition, and you\'re not going nuts about it.

It\'s all well and good to say, \"let\'s select a random scapegoat to start a clampdown on diving\" but by the day after it was already clear that and Eduardo ban wasn\'t the start of a clampdown, it was a witch-hunt.

Also, you\'re also pooing on your standing as an ex-refereee by insisting that UEFA throw out a decision of the referee in the course of a game which both himself and the referee\'s assesor stood by afterwards.

This was another example of how mob thinking can corrupt an ideal and seriously derail justice.

The way it should work is that UEFA or any of you diving fundamentalists, declare that after a certain date, there will be a clampdown on diving and every single case thereafter is then brought under censure.

For me, the false outrage over Eduardo was like the government declaring teen pregnancy a criminal offence after they discovered my teenager\'s pregnancy.

It\'s just annoying that you claim moral highground but are not capable of letting fairness and common sense trump your agendas.


Arsenal Man, September 22, 2009 at 5:28 pm
Keep grinding that axe fatty!


ScotchEggsRule, September 22, 2009 at 5:31 pm
Rubbish article with only personal thoughts and very little fact based contribution.
there\'s 10 minutes of my life wasted on this drivel.


I saw it, September 22, 2009 at 5:45 pm
You fail to mention that Rooney dived in the Arsenal match and when he was wearing his countries colours.

Both were completed perfectly and each time the ref was conned, now what would happen if we started pointing the finger at poor refereeing and started to blame the officials?

That would be a great idea, ban the officials who give the bad decisions - or would that be a witch hunt!

People have always \'won\' penalties and even the ex-players give a good TV talk on the matter, at the end of the day this fires up supporters and the team it was against. Passion for the game is passion for the game and the supporters hate to feel hard done by but that is football, jeer and boo the opposition as is there right.

Eduardo was clipped on the heel, fair enough it was a good dive but after the fact and to ensure the ref had no option but to award the penalty. Had Eduardo not gone down in such a manner, the ref has a decision to make and may not have given the correct decision of a penalty. Now, cheating is starting to dive prior to contact i.e. Rooney who was spread eagle before contact was made - now that is deceiving the ref, the big pity is that Rooney could have jumped the goal keepers challenge and put the ball in the back of the net, that is if it wasn\'t already off the pitch in the hoardings (I thought it had to be under control of the player?).

So lets start with the referees, ban them when they make a bad decision or would that be a witch hunt?




bedy, September 22, 2009 at 9:02 pm
Clowns like you should not be writing sport news,how on earth you miss injustice at Chelsea(denial of penality to Robie Kean)and you find it easy to defend 5min extra on top of extra mins at Man U,everybody knew that the time keeping was wrong but only you.Officials in EPL are so biased to some clubs you can not write about that,Rooney,Gerad,Yong,Owen e.t.c are diving as if they are in swimming classes every week but you can not see, only for you to advocate Eduardo to be scape goat and you know it and everybody knows it he is not a regular diver,even you never write once to condemned Ronaldo while at Man U.
So go and find a better job if you can not be objective in your writing as it is a disgrace,no wonder English players dont do well in international matches look at it how many times they have been sent off on international duties,because your officials and people like you are not they to lie for them.


Menace, September 22, 2009 at 9:11 pm
The Eduardo situation ended correctly. The added on time is a farce at Old Trafford anytime. There were 6 goals that were celebrated why was only one considered for added time?


Menace, September 22, 2009 at 9:16 pm
Jeff Winter another pompous referee. The only thing that most referees are good for is blowing on whistles. There are many carnivals that need you. Please dont write about football because the Laws of the game are abused by referees more than by players.


Elle, Deputy Editor, September 23, 2009 at 9:51 am
gigbrin - Jeff is correct for the continental spelling but I have changed to Uefa at your request.


A, October 7, 2009 at 8:05 pm
There was an equally justified and more obvious penalty appeal for Arsenal towards the end too, so surely 7-3?


steve, October 7, 2009 at 8:10 pm
What about the rest of the game. did you even watch it??


funbi, October 7, 2009 at 8:37 pm
the writer is just an idiot!


Old Toilet, October 7, 2009 at 8:45 pm
Remember Rooney\'s blatant dive that ended Arsenal\'s undefeated run ?
There was absolutely NO contact between Rooney and Arsenal defender.


wondrinfree, October 7, 2009 at 9:30 pm
Jeff you really need to show some independance and integrity, or atleast watch the game rather than listen to the post match codswollop. Arsenal also had a valid penalty turned down which you and every other commentator forgets or declines to mention.

The assumption that the outcome could have be changed by the first penalty falls a bit flat when you think Arsenal had already gone behind twice and come back. I\'m not sure the top four clubs get phased like that.

If it was in the last few minutes there may be a case but so early on and with Arsenal similarly denied, hopes of a different outcome were fanciful.


Gooner 48, October 8, 2009 at 12:08 am
Fat Sam, like Fergusmoan was moaning about the ref by way of deflecting from the fact that his team were lucky not to concede ten or more. Have you ever heard Wenger moan at a ref? No you haven\'t.

So you like all the others bang on about a pen. What about Arsenal\'s pen which wasn\'t given? 7-4


Kris Everton, October 8, 2009 at 1:23 am
B/S!


Grant, October 8, 2009 at 10:25 am
Not only is this writer stupid, but his lack of football knowledge is almost embarrassing.

Please explain the possession and shots on goals which both fell Everton\'s way, and tell me Stoke still deserved to win. Stoke got lucky to even get the 1 point. They didn\'t deserve any. Everton outplayed them all over the pitch, the fact that they managed to sneak one goal just means they got lucky... but in no way did they deserve to win. Everton deserved all 3 points.

You (writer) are about the biggest tool I\'ve ever heard of.


Biggy G, October 8, 2009 at 1:37 pm
Well thanks goodness that he\'s a writer and not a referee otherwise we\'d be watching more bull***t refereeing once again in this league. Clearly we outclassed Stoke who are personally a really garbage outfit that should have been smashed that day!! Keep writing your crap Jeff!!!


Barry Cass, October 8, 2009 at 3:55 pm
Jeff Jeff Jeff, there you go again with your normal anti-Everton rant ! Still haven\'t forgiven David Moyes for him correctly stating you were more interested in your suntan than giving Everton the correct decisions !

Now for sunday\'s match against Stoke, you may have a point that Baines nudged Delap on one of Stoke\'s rare visit\'s into Everton\'s half however, you don\'t mention the TWO STONEWALL penalties that Everton should have had in the 1st half. The pull on Fellaini of a corner when he only had to head the ball into the net and the BLATANT handball from Ryan Shawcross from Bilyaletdinov\'s goal bound shot. I think the USELESS Andre Mariner had spent saturday night on the phone to you about how to rob Everton blind !!!!


James, October 9, 2009 at 6:44 pm
I heard an interview with the journalist from the Liverpool Echo, who thought the draw a fair result. That\'s good enough for me.

Who deserved to win is not the point of this article though.

For Stoke to have been awarded a penalty would have been harsh. Not because it wasn\'t a foul in the box, it was - but because you rarely see them given. The Shawcross \'handball\' would have been a travesty though. He was facing the ball side-on from a short distance away, and actually made a sharp movement of his arm to draw it out of the way. Never a penalty.

So in conclusion. 2-1 Stoke.


Michael, October 9, 2009 at 6:54 pm
Even if you think a penalty should have been awarded, you are then assuming that it would have been scored.


John Henry, October 9, 2009 at 6:58 pm
Well, jeff only has eyes for arsenal .. in a negative way. So, don\'t expect him to comment on arsenal unless it is negative. Don\'t believe me? Then review his blog for the past year.


tom svendsen, October 9, 2009 at 7:26 pm
Jeff..

what really puzzles me..is how the media yourself included..seems to when it comes to Arsenal finds it easy to mention only the mistakes..and yes i agree with you it was a pen...but like in almost any other game it was overlooked..and im not even going to bother discussing with you Arsenal\'s pens which have been overlooked this season..this things have a way of even out...
Jeff one solid question how on earth do you expect people to take anything you have to say about Arsenal seriously..this year we have taken so much shit from the media its incredible..Eduardo..among other things...why cant you be proud over the fact that you British have a team that does most things right..and dont by themselves a place in heaven like chelski..mancity..and others...and actually plays the game like no other in England...

no my firend get over it...be serious and people will listen to what you have to say...other than that have a great Weekend..

Best Regards Tom


Alex Sinclair, October 9, 2009 at 8:39 pm
a/Why do you bother responding to rants?

b/ Why do you respond to legitimately phrased replies when you say things like \'my opinion, my column\'. Presumably it\'s your ball and you\'re taking it home.


ChopperHMK, October 9, 2009 at 11:38 pm
Jeff

I have to applaud you for taking your time to respond to what would be mainly drivel comments from people who dont seem to actually watch the game.

Baines/Delap incident could have been a penalty and I have seen them given, but equally there are many instances where similiar challenges are not punished.

By the letter of the law, Baines pushed delap and therefore its a foul, but by the letter of the law there would be numerous players sent off for foul and abusive language (e.g. a player says \"F*ck off\" in your direction), or numerous penalties awarded for pulling/pushing inside the box. referees sometimes use their discretion regarding the \"seriousness\" off the offence.

The question I have is, why is there a major reluctance for referees to give in-direct free kicks (when warranted) inside the box. the only time you seem to see them given is for a keeper handling the ball from a backpass?

Thanks


Dan, October 12, 2009 at 7:23 pm
Dear Mr Winter,

I like this response thing you do... It is nice to hear what you have to say in response to comments, and can give a greater insight into how you (and perhaps other refs) see things. I am disappointed however, that you did not reply to a comment I made about an article you wrote about Eduardo being a blatant cheat etc. I was hoping to read what you were thinking after you read that comment. Oh well, I suppose. I have to assume that perhaps you did not because it was too challenging?

Kind regards

Dan


Blakeney, October 12, 2009 at 7:57 pm
Amazing that you don\'t see Gallas taken out in the move that leads up to Vermaelen\'s tackle; or the stonewall penalty when, a little later, Nzonzi mows down the self same Gallas in their goal area.
But, then, Jeff, that was you I saw at The Emirates Cup in the Rangers\' end, wasn\'t it? And mighty fine you looked, all decked out in the \'gers kit - so what should we expect?


Dave, October 12, 2009 at 9:47 pm
Should have been a penalty and Vermaelen should have walked, therefore he wouldn\'t have been on the pitch to head Hoilett\'s effort against the post. That makes it 6-4! Makes it look like we gave Arsenal a game now!!


banduan, October 13, 2009 at 2:29 am
as an Arse fan, I have to say Jeff has been fairly even handed so far. He\'s missed some points (Gallas shoulda got a peno vs Blackburn) but we all do.


nick, October 13, 2009 at 11:35 am
I\'d hate to see what these Arsenal fans would be like if you reversed a result against them. Jeff only changed the score by one goal,you still won and you still moan.
Try having two minutes of highlights every week on MOTD to base descisions on every week.Unlike the half hour each of the big 4 get.


Gian Carlo, October 13, 2009 at 1:24 pm
David Dunn could have been red carded for barging into Mannone.

Just before the half, Van Persie was fouled but still managed to play Cesc through for a 2 on 1 attack which could have very well been a goal, unfortunately the linesman somehow ridiculously ruled that Van Persie had done the fouling and he was booked for dissent.

Blackburn\'s Dunn had a penalty shout, but that was in no way a sending off offence, and Dunn shouldn\'t have been on the pitch for lunging at Mannone earlier.

Then Arsenal had a clear penalty shout at the end of the match which was not given.

8-3


Kiri pegasiou, October 14, 2009 at 6:41 pm
Dear Mr winters
When i saw penalty I shouted cold stone penalty, (i\'m an arsenal fan) I was a bit suprised it was not given, but on replays I felt that because the challenge outside box ( i think it was gallas or diaby) then made dunne lose his footing. So maybe the ref didn\'t give penalty because he lost control of ball???? I would appreciate your answer.

kind regards

kiri



wondrinfree, October 14, 2009 at 7:51 pm
Jef

Many people critisise Refs for their decision making at Old Trafford where Man U almost always seem to benefit. Rather than bias, (which I don\'t think exists) I was wondering if the massive and vocal crowd support puts pressure on Refs who unknowingly or are intimidated into making more bad decisions than normal.

When you were there did you find it hard to not be influenced?


Chico Guerrera, October 15, 2009 at 10:41 am
Hold on. If you\'re going to focus on one game, the least you could do is watch it in entirety. Otherwise who can you give a fair and balanced analysis?


 
Name:
Email:
Your Comment:


   COLUMNISTS


© All written site content is copyright SportingPreview.com 2009, unless otherwise stated, and is not to be used without prior permission.
  SPORTS NEWS
  Cricket
  Football
  Horse Racing
  Industry News
  Novelty
  Other Sports
  Rugby
  Tennis
  DAILY
  Racing Tips
  Greyhounds
  Paddy Power
  Premium Tips
  WEEKLY
  Paddy Power
  Betfair Previews
  MORE
  Betting Diary
  Guaranteed Profit Bets
  MISCELLANEOUS
  Links
  RSS Feeds
   Sitemap | Search Site | Terms and Privacy | Set as Homepage | Contact
This website designed, maintained and managed by Waking Lion ©2009