MAIN MENU
   SPORTS NEWS
   DAILY ARTICLES
   WEEKLY ARTICLES
   GENERAL ARTICLES
   MISCELLANEOUS


VILLAIN OF THE WEEK - THE COMMUNITY SHIELD: YOUR RESPONSES
Jeff Winter, 12 Aug 2009

The first Villain of the Week of the season has created a response, as usual.

Also, as usual, there is an element of bias in readers' replies, dependant on which team they support. An example of this is the reply from the Manchester United fan that I have had to edit to make it semi-readable and understandable!!

Your points are somewhat lost on me when you can't even compose a legible sentence or two!!!

Article Continues Below...



I still maintain that Foy did NOT play advantage. He did not signal as such and, as usual, the media and experts have possibly jumped to the wrong conclusion.

We will never know the truth, as Foy was not allowed to comment after the game.

By the following day, the FA/PGMOL had time to get their heads together and Dermott Gallagher was able to present the case for the defence.

My view is that it was a foul and should have been penalised.

Yes, there was exaggeration and yes, the United players did surround the ref.

We all know that little or no action is ever taken unless it is a very extreme case, whilst managers continue to berate officials without any fear of action.

To suggest that the ref should be banned is ridiculous (by the way, it has nothing to do with FIFA). He made a mistake. If every ref who makes a mistake is banned, we wouldn't have any games.

The incident did highlight a problem though. Everyone wants to see advantage being played, but perhaps the rugby rule would benefit the game. It is not going to happen though.

Players feigning injury does not help the situation either and this is why we still have the ruling that players have to leave the field for treatment.

Another season and the same old problems persist. We need stronger refereeing but they must be supported by the authorities.

Here are your responses to my original article:

************************

From: Sagar

He has dug a hole for himself.

But this gives the FA/Premier League/Refs' Association the chance to sort this issue out once and for all before the season starts, when these sort of decisions really start to matter!!

************************

From: Baby Blue

I would not let Evra off scott free. He was checked by Ballack, of that there is no doubt, but he went down holding his face which was patently NOT the contact point.

He was trying to get Ballack into trouble.

This is probably why the referee did not stop the game to allow treatment - he didn't need treatment.

But Evra (like many others, Drogba more than most) stayed down, not helping his team and kept up the pretence.

If he had not tried to make a meal of the situation, and advantage had been played, then no-one would be talking about this today.

Note also the number of Man U players surrounding, pushing and barging the referee. No mention of that in any of the media. One rule for them...

************************

From: Maka

What's up Jeff? No mention of United players crowding the ref? Oh wait, we are only supposed to complain about that when it involves Chelsea.

You used the entire '08 season to have a go at Chelsea when they crowded the ref. United did it AGAIN on Sunday and you sit silent.

Surprising? No.

************************

From: Isaidso, in response to Maka

There's surrounding the referee, and then there's surrounding the referee in the LUNATIC way with murderous intent that Chelsea players did, and were rightfully banned for several CL games for.

United players weren't out of control, and were right to approach Foy as the player was on the ground too long.

I watched the video of the incident and Ballack DID hit both Evra's chest and the side of his face because his arm kept flailing upwards.

Ballack admtted the foul and he acknowledged that the ref should have stopped play.

Jeff is right in his assessment. If there is no advantage, then play has to be brought back, a free kick awarded, and a card shown.

But then Jeff was a ref who never shirked the hard decisions - one of the few refs to do so I might add.

Well said Jeff, and you're right of course.

************************

From: Brett cfc

When Carrick was put in position to put through a chip pass to the strikers, was that not receiving advantage? The ball had moved through two players.

How can you decide after TWO passes that there's no advantage after all? If you get to that, then you might as well pull it up after two minutes or when there's a turnover in possession after 90 seconds and the team didn't score - and that's not how football is refereed (unlike rugby).

Evra simulated that he was hit in the head and rolled around with his hands on his face. No wonder Foy didn't whistle.

Carrick saw Evra rolling on the ground, and played the lofted pass anyway, after receiving it from Rooney.

Why should Chelsea kick it out if United didn't? And why should the referee stop play if United were happy to take advantage of getting the ball back? Nonsense.

************************

From: ManU

The referee spoilt the game and should be suspended by FIFA.

Then there was Ballack, who was out to gain vengence against Evra due to a long term conflict.

Firstly, Ballack's play-acting caused Evra to get a yellow card when it was obviously a good tackle.

Then came the bad tackle which the referee should have yellow carded Ballack for but instead he closed his eyes when the foul was committed in front of him.

The equalising goal should not have stood because Drogba clearly fouled Ben Foster to allow Carvalho to score and we have seen other referees give free kicks against Drogba but Foy chose to close his eyes.

************************

From: pjch

Interesting to read all the comments made so far.

Was it a foul by Ballack? Yes. Even he admitted it himself.

Should Foy have blown for a free kick? Yes.

If he had done his job properly than all the stories and discussions would not have happened since the end of the match.

COMMENT ON THIS ARTICLE

SEND THIS TO A FRIEND
BACK TO VILLAIN OF THE WEEK INDEX
A GUARANTEED PROFIT OF AT LEAST �47.03 ON EVERTON v ARSENAL

The Premiership is back this weekend and did you know that it is possible to win money on Saturday evening's clash between Everton and Arsenal, whatever the result?

The game kicks off at 5.30pm UK Time and we can guarantee you a profit of at least �47.03, whatever the result of the match. All you have to do is click here and follow the simple instructions and then sit back and enjoy the game. At full-time, you will be at least �47.03 better off, whatever the result of the match.

CLICK HERE FOR A GUARANTEED PROFIT OF AT LEAST �47.03 ON EVERTON v ARSENAL

Comments On This Article

fergal, August 12, 2009 at 3:19 pm
In response to \"Isaidso, in response to Maka\", Jeff never shirked the hard decision?

How come Dennis Wise was still on the pitch with 5 mins to go (so that he could sub himself to get a cheer from Millwall fans) in the FA Cup Final of 2004? How come Paul Scholes didn\'t get a penalty in the same game?


eoo_net, August 12, 2009 at 3:55 pm
From eoo_net
In response to Maka!
Did you talk about crowding the ref? Can Maka let the people know what could have happened if Wayne Rooney, or any United player ever snatched the ref\'s red card? Jokes aside, the refs are blatantly biased against Man United. Shame on them United took the title last year. As you can see they are bent on stopping ManU this year, otherwise you would have nothing to discuss, shear jealousy.


Chelsea, August 12, 2009 at 4:54 pm
Hey, I don\'t understand what the fuss is about yes it was a free kick and the ref game advantage and united took it and lost the ball. Its their own fault, if ManU thought that their player was really hurt they would have stopped the ball. Also how come nobody mentions anything about Rooner scoring the 2nd goal from an offside position. Ooooh I know cause that would go agains ManU. NOW SHUT THE Fxck UP.


daddyblue, August 12, 2009 at 8:52 pm
But Roney was offside goal should not have been allowed


 
Name:
Email:
Your Comment:


   COLUMNISTS


© All written site content is copyright SportingPreview.com 2009, unless otherwise stated, and is not to be used without prior permission.
  SPORTS NEWS
  Cricket
  Football
  Horse Racing
  Industry News
  Novelty
  Other Sports
  Rugby
  Tennis
  DAILY
  Racing Tips
  Greyhounds
  Paddy Power
  Premium Tips
  WEEKLY
  Paddy Power
  Betfair Previews
  MORE
  Betting Diary
  Guaranteed Profit Bets
  MISCELLANEOUS
  Links
  RSS Feeds
   Sitemap | Search Site | Terms and Privacy | Set as Homepage | Contact
This website designed, maintained and managed by Waking Lion ©2009