| MAIN MENU |
| SPORTS NEWS |
|
|
|
| DAILY ARTICLES |
|
|
|
| WEEKLY ARTICLES |
|
|
|
| GENERAL ARTICLES |
|
|
|
| MISCELLANEOUS |
|
|
 |
|
|
|
VILLAIN OF THE WEEK - YOUR RESPONSES TO THE MANCHESTER UNITED v ARSENAL GAME II
Jeff Winter, 9 Sep 2009
The following points go over the same ground regarding my Villain Of The Week article from last week.
Firstly, let me point out that
I am probably the only ref of my generation who hasn't sent an Arsenal player off.
I sent Roy Keane and Gary Neville off (at Old Trafford against Man City) and put
Fergie in the stands. Therefore to accuse me of United bias is rather silly.
Wenger has his points but his failure to condemn the Eduardo dive was his biggest mistake.
Basically, most managers are the same. Funnily enough, just like fans.
I deeply respect your opinions. I am very critical of punditry in general and you're
at the very top of my list save one or two.
But when you talk about fouls by Arsenal and stats about them, you must have been
looking at parallel reality facts.
Opta looked at the last three meetings between Arsenal and Man United at Old Trafford.
Arsenal made 44 fouls and got 17 bookings, Man United made 48 and got five bookings.
They've had four penalties against Arsenal in the last seven games at Old Trafford.
See here
You're also misreading Wenger's point. The point is that Fletcher fouled
continually and was not booked by the referee for it. You should address that in my
opinion.
Wenger is also correct that persistently fouling goes against the spirit of the game.
************************
Article Continues Below...
************************
From: Ganesh
Absolutely biased article Jeff.
First of all, being English, you could not even
spell "character assassination" correctly. What in the world is character
assignation?
Secondly, if YOU actually look at the statistics, then United have had five yellow cards
for the past 48 fouls against Arsenal whilst Arsenal have had more yellow cards dished
out for 44 fouls.
You know, more than diving, it's hypocrisy like this which kills the game.
************************
From: Richard
Last three meetings at Old Trafford:
Man Utd, 48 fouls, 5 yellow cards
Arsenal, 44 fouls, 17 yellow cards
I don't think that shows Arsenal as the villains. It does show how these games are
being refereed.
************************
From: Richard Shepherd
Hi again Jeff
I wanted to test your opinion on the diving issue because I'm not in agreement with
your view of the Eduardo dive being 'disgusting'.
If you compare Eduardo's and
Rooney's actions in the penalty incidents, I believe that as strikers, they
are almost identical.
Both were looking for penalties in situations when they were highly unlikely to score
from normal play.
Both just beat the keeper to the ball and were prepared to go down
(Rooney is clearly on the way down before he's touched).
The difference was that
Boruc managed to hold back whereas Almunia didn't.
This means that Rooney got a legitimate
penalty but Eduardo was castigated and banned. It is interesting that Raul did exactly the same
thing in Real's match but won the penalty.
I believe there's a lot of nonsense talked about 'contact', particularly on TV.
Refs never give fouls just for contact so players go down and then get a foul. Spanish football has dozens of incidents every weekend.
It's part of football, like
it or not. And clearly we do like it because Ronaldo was voted footballer of the year and
used this tactic as much as anyone. Except maybe Drogba!
The fuss over Eduardo was generated by our media coverage and he has been unfairly
treated.
To be honest, I hate all diving and simultation but it's part of the game now.
Richard
CHECK OUT JEFF WINTER'S OFFICIAL WEBSITE BY CLICKING HERE
COMMENT ON THIS ARTICLE
BACK TO VILLAIN OF THE WEEK INDEX
A GUARANTEED PROFIT OF AT LEAST �37.00 ON TOTTENHAM HOTSPUR v MANCHESTER UNITED
The Premier League resumes this weekend and did you know that it is possible to win money on Saturday evening's clash between Tottenham Hotspur and Manchester United, whatever the result?
The game kicks off at 5.30pm UK Time and we can guarantee you a profit of at least �37.00, whatever the result of the match. All you have to do is follow the simple instructions below and then sit back and enjoy the game. At full-time, you will be at least �37.00 better off, whatever the result of the match.
A GUARANTEED PROFIT OF AT LEAST �37.00 ON TOTTENHAM HOTSPUR v MANCHESTER UNITED
Comments On This Article
rayman, September 9, 2009 at 5:16 pm Fair play Jeff for publishing the comments and your answers to them. While you may not be biased towards Utd I think its a reasonable conclusion to draw when your original article was so one sided and lauded the ref\'s performance. Also your continual avoidance of the questions about the persistent fouling by Utd, especially Fletcher just makes it worse. Its a straightforward question - when you look at the game again does it not look like Utd are getting away with persistent fouling without the ref taking the usual action (strong word after the first few, then a booking for someone to show it won\'t be tolerated). Its just baffling for any non-Utd supporter to hear you then praise the ref as having done a great job - he was awful, it was a terrible refereeing display and it certainly affected the game.
erik, September 9, 2009 at 5:23 pm Jeff, the 2 best managers of the Premiership (Fergie and Wenger) both know that you cant criticize your own players to the media.
Why do you think Wenger just says: \"I did not see it?\"
I am so angry with how these 2 incidents are seen because they are both dives but Rooney\'s has so much more to it... in a way you could say that he is a better actor and if medals were given out he would win the Gold and Eduardo the Silva (Silver)
Rooney\'s is a better dive because:
1) He \'makes sure\' there is contact with Almunia, look at how his legs suddenly seem to just give out and land on Almunia before any contact is made...
2) He has the cheek to look at the referee and claim for it...
Eduardo:
1) Didnt look for contact but apparently there was but IMO not enough to go down.
2) Never looked at the ref and claimed for a penalty.
Oh yes, and what about the penalty in against Slovakia? he doesnt get any stick for that either even though HE FOULS the player and injures him too! oh yeah, AND HE CLAIMS FOR A PENALTY TOO!
If Eduardo gets banned for this and nothing is done about Rooney, the message this sends out is: \"if you are going to dive, then make sure you touch the keeper\"
It will not stop diving, it will encourage \'better diving of the Rooney category\'.
the GuNNER, September 10, 2009 at 12:26 am besides touching the keeper,make sure you are English to survive the wrath of the English media.
|
|
|
|
| COLUMNISTS |
|
|
 |
|
|