| MAIN MENU |
| SPORTS NEWS |
|
|
|
| SPECIAL ARTICLES |
|
|
|
| GENERAL ARTICLES |
|
|
|
| MISCELLANEOUS |
|
|
 |
|
|
|
VILLAIN OF THE WEEK - MY COMMENTS ON FERGIE: YOUR RESPONSES
Jeff Winter, 12 Oct 2009
My comments about Fergie have naturally caused anger from United fans. As
usual, I have replied to their comments.
************************
From: Dennis Axisa - Malta
Sorry Jeff
For me you got it wrong. Okay, it might be that Sir Alex jumped the
line a bit but I don't expect that referees do what they want without being
criticised.
So if a player or manager does something they get punished for it and the
referees get away with everything.
No, man. For me this is wrong and Sir Alex has many times been proven right
when he has complained about mishaps by the referees.
Jeff's reply
Anyone is entitled to an opinion, but managers are expected to
adhere to a code of conduct. SAF clearly thinks that he is beyond that.
His accusations this time were wide of the mark and, as most people believe, were
an ill-advised attempt to defer criticism from his team selection and
United's performance.
************************
Column Continues Below...
************************
From: Slick
You really always have been a bit of a tosser, haven't you?
He doesn't deserve the title Sir? Tell that to all the young managers he helps
out during their time of need and some of Britain's top sports stars whose
careers he has nurtured.
Maybe Fergie did go a bit far but, to a certain point,
he was right. The game was getting slowed down and this time was not getting
added on. For example, there was no additional time for the goal scored in
stoppage time.
Jeff's reply
You have me bang to rights Slick, especially when alone in hotel
rooms!!!
In no way do I want to detract from the excellent work that SAF has
done and the respect he has earned during his very successful career as a
manager.
However, all of this does not give him the right to behave like he
does, with far too regular images of him ranting and raving and spewing out
foul mouthed abuse when being watched by a nation of youngsters.
Surely, this is not what is expected of a knight of the realm, is it?
************************
From: zuco
Hi Jeff
Following your delusional ramblings in the media about Sir Alex Ferguson
recently, I felt compelled to write a blog about them so you could see a
United fan's viewpoint on them.
I write for www.manutdtalk.com, one of the most popular United forums on the
net and I'd love to be able to get some responses from you.
Now I understand that being a media-whore requires you to charge a fee
before you spout your rhetoric to the unwanting masses, but unfortunately
our website is run on a very tight budget.
We'd see it as a sign of good
will and a willingness to explain that your comments were not borne out of
jealousy and bitterness if you would take part in a short interview for the
site.
Jeff's reply
Hi Zuco
Firstly, you are a smooth talker when asking me to contribute to your site. I
suppose your favourite chat up line is "Hey slag, fancy a shag?"
Nevertheless, I have read your article and respect your opinions. We are all
entitled to them.
The face on the photo you used is not bitterness towards
United and Sir Alex, but it's what happens to you after a lifetime of
supporting Middlesbrough!!!
Could I first take you up on your description of me as a media-whore. I
wonder, had I been a former player or an out of work manager, whether or not you
would have used that title. Perhaps, as a former referee, you are just not
happy that I am regularly asked my opinion.
Could I re-iterate that I am
asked my opinion, I do not go asking to go on TV, radio or to do articles for
newspapers. This suggests to me that they want my opinion from an unbiased
angle and also from a refereeing perspective.
The authorities will not allow
refs to clear up incidents post match - they put forward employees to spout the
party line. I am free of ties to the FA or Premier League and can therefore
give honest opinions without prejudice or favour.
The one thing that is apparent from having opinions is that the fans of the
club I have given an opinion against naturally do not like it. I
have ironically continuously been referred to as a closet United fan when I
have given an opinion that is pro-United, most recently when I supported
Martin Atkinson's assessment of the time that was added on at the end of the
derby match victory.
I hope that whilst you describe my opinions as a bitter rant, you won't mind
me addressing a couple of other points in your article.
I can assure you
that I would have no hesitation in speaking directly to Sir Alex or anyone
else. We all only ever learn anything if we listen to other people's
points of view.
If you read my article in its entirety, you will note that I
stated that I have the utmost respect for United and their manager. Indeed,
like any fair minded football fan, they would have loved to have him as
manager of their club and to have enjoyed the success that he has brought to
United.
His wealth is well earned and I have never been jealous of anybody
in my life. In fact, good luck to everybody. I am only interested in my own
wealth, no one else's, as their good fortune is of no consequence to me.
This brings me on to media work. If you were asked to give a
professional opinion and were offered payment, would you refuse? I do draw
the line at the big money that is offered for digging the dirt. Believe it
or not, I do have principles.
Having said all of that, I have looked beyond the name calling and read your
comments about referees and take your point.
I have, for many a long year,
defended the "penalties at Old Trafford argument" as common sense says that
United, and indeed most of the biggest clubs, win the majority of their home
games and are in control for the majority of those games. Therefore, the chances
of the opposition winning a penalty at OT is far less than at a lesser club's ground. Statistics cannot and do not tell the full story.
Some refs are not as strong
as others unfortunately and there have been instances when they have frozen
when officiating the biggest teams. This is also a widely held belief within
the game.
I still believe that Fergie has gone too far this time and will get a severe
ban from the FA. If not, the Respect campaign is in tatters. I would,
incidentally, be saying exactly the same thing if it was Wenger, Benitez or any
other manager.
I hope that these views, if not agreed with, represent my actual feelings. I
am happy to answer any further questions you may have.
Many may not be interested in my views, but I give a view from a side of the
game that is seldom heard. Some actually see beyond their personal club
bias and actually appreciate that.
Enjoy your football like I enjoy mine.
Best Wishes
Jeff
************************
From: Alwyn Pickard
Sorry Jeff, you are wrong. Most fans think referees are petty and
vindictive. Fergie only voices what most people think but do not like to
say.
If you doubt the respect people in the game have for Fergie, you should
talk to fellow managers and players. Club chairmen as well.
Incidently, Chelsea are the team held in the least regard by supporters.
Jeff's reply
Judging by what I read and hear on national phone-in programmes, I
would have to disagree with you.
Admittedly, any team that is successful or which
inherits success by the cheque book is not loved by opposing supporters, but
the behaviour of SAF hardly endears the club to anyone.
Refs are supposed to
apply the Laws fairly, however, even if a ref is deemed petty, this does not
warrant personal and inaccurate verbal assaults form Fergie.
He has gone too far
this time, and his excuse for an apology was too little too late. Its sincerity
can also be questioned as he still finished his statement off by having
another go.
Managers will always use refs as the scapegoat, whether they are
guilty or not. Opinions on decisions are bound to be different, but no-one
has ever publicly questioned the fitness of the officials.
He is on his
own on this one. He should be facing a European style stadium ban, not a
touchline ban. If he doesn't then the FA have bottled it.
Best Wishes
Jeff
CHECK OUT JEFF WINTER'S OFFICIAL WEBSITE BY CLICKING HERE
HAVE YOU GOT WHAT IT TAKES TO BE THE LAST MAN STANDING?
COMMENT ON THIS ARTICLE
BACK TO VILLAIN OF THE WEEK INDEX
A GUARANTEED PROFIT OF AT LEAST �28.80 ON URUGUAY v ARGENTINA
There's a full round of World Cup qualifying matches this midweek and did you know that it is possible to win money on Wednesday evening's clash between Uruguay and Argentina, whatever the result?
The game kicks off at 11.00pm UK Time and we can guarantee you a profit of at least �28.80, whatever the result of the match. All you have to do is follow the simple instructions below and then sit back and enjoy the game. At full-time, you will be at least �28.80 better off, whatever the result of the match.
A GUARANTEED PROFIT OF AT LEAST �28.80 ON URUGUAY v ARGENTINA
Comments On This Article
Scott the Red, October 12, 2009 at 6:49 pm That was probably one of the most sad and pathetic \"articles\" I have ever read.
My favourite part was: \'Hey slag, fancy a shag?\'. What are you on?
Plenty of managers have claimed that referees have been intentionally biased towards another team and received no stadium ban. Jose Mourinho lied and claimed he saw the opposition manager going in to the referee\'s office at half time and said he was therefore unsurprised by the decisions that went against his team in the second half.
This is a bitter, biased and quite frankly, rather pathetic piece of writing. I\'m cringing on your behalf.
newton, October 12, 2009 at 8:00 pm jeff winter,another loser who thinks he knows all about the modern game.hopeless guy.a real twat.he\'s been waiting for a long time to say this and he finally got his chance.how sore and numb can and numb skull be.
daveob82, October 12, 2009 at 8:03 pm Whatever happened to the old phrase \"Respect is earned\".
TO assume just because a person has become a referee that they automatically qualify for this respect is ludicrous.... the same as players, managers, coaches, coaches, teachers in fact every profession.... if someone deserves respect they will get it.....
I find it laughable that all of these grown man straight throwing their toys out of the pram and childishly state they won\'t play anymore because the bold man called him names.
The FA does need to address the issues of respect towards refs... but it needs to start with refs themselves....
Jef your comments (for example the one Scott has mentioned above) won\'t endear you to the \"let\'s respect referees\" group.
A man who was in your position should have a bit of sense.
MShannan, October 12, 2009 at 8:31 pm Well one thing is for certain, which I am glad about! Referees will be MORE under the spotlight in how they referee United games after all the hysterical rantings of the referees union. Typical militants running the workers Union. If ref\'s decide to exact their own revenge on Man Utd because of all the ill will they feel towards SAF, then ref\'s will be all over the press instead of SAF, which is how it should be. Talk about over reaction from the little men ref\'s on parade in front of TV and Media! This referee however I happen to like very much - sorry it was him who copped it. Nevertheless, a good few ref\'s miss a lot in the game, because they don\'t keep up with the play. There I am not afraid to say it, even if others are. Free country, and free speech!
john, October 12, 2009 at 10:47 pm I have to feel a bit sorry for SAF this time!
Managers have said *far* worst about referees than this and weve got people calling for him to be banned?
Could this over-reaction from the referees be because he spoke the truth?
The ref in question is clearly out of shape and he had a shocker of a match.
Fair enough - punish SAF for how he went about saying what he did. But lets be consistent (a foreign concept with EPL referees I know) and lets not gloss over the bigger issue.
Which isn\'t that SAF is a bit of a mouthy moaner.
It\'s that the referees need to shape up or ship out.
Ren, October 13, 2009 at 7:20 am All this so called \"proof\" being offered to justify Mr Wiley\'s fitness is ridiculous.
If a player turned out on the pitch looking fatter than Billy Bunter in a duffle coat, all the statistics in the world would not stop people from making allegations about his fitness.
Why should referees be any different?
The shameful way these comments have been blown up by the media and referees to whip up ill feeling about a manager they do not like is outrageous.
Shame on you.
Shakshamboo, October 13, 2009 at 4:14 pm Can anybody tell me why pointing out a physical fitness problem in a ref has been classified as a disrespectful thing. Is a referee immune to being physically unfit. Its not like SAF has criticized any judgment the ref gave during the game.
Even if we assume that he was not completely right in his remarks this still does not in anyway go in the category of disrespect. This whole thing is being given a negative twist by the media and the people in the Referee union and other referees (retired or otherwise) have seen this as the perfect platform to attract that attention towards themselves and their rather boring life and try to earn some fast buck.
Regarding the statistics of the said Referee having run more than most of the players. I would just like point out the simple fact that most players only run when the ball is near their area (e.g. Defenders and holding midfielders). Does that mean that a Referee is fitter than most players. That is just ridiculous.
Franco Mizzi, October 14, 2009 at 3:52 pm Mr. Wiley looks very much out of shape and thats a fact. Refs think that they are untouchables an thats a fact. We have a proffessional set up in football from Board Room to kit manager to player/manager etc but still have part time refs and dats a fact. Statistics provided don\'t proof anything and dats a fact. Refs do\'t want video technology so they can remain dictators of our beloved game and when all other major sports have addressed the issue and either use technology or as in tennis a game played by a maximum of 4 players has a Ref, an Umpire and Line Judges and this a non contact sport, by the way dats a fact. Another fact is that you Mr. Winter had a big attitude problem when you reffed matches and used to hate it when you reffed us as you always wanted to be the centre of attention and dats a fact. Take it on your chin just like your Prime Minister has or are refs a higher authority then the PM and Government. It\'s a bit rich that one can bring a whole parliamant to it\'s knees and yet can not state the obvious that Mr. Wiley is rather overweight for a PL ref. Carry on with your life and you can hate SAF as much as you want as what matters is that we adore him especially for stating the truth when no one else wants to hear it.
|
|
|
|
| COLUMNISTS |
|
|
 |
|
|