MAIN MENU
   SPORTS NEWS
   SPECIAL ARTICLES
   GENERAL ARTICLES
   MISCELLANEOUS


VILLAIN OF THE WEEK - TOTTENHAM HOTSPUR v SUNDERLAND: YOUR RESPONSES
Jeff Winter, 17 Nov 2009

Bookmark and Share

There have been many comments generated from my Villain of the Week article regarding the Tottenham and Sunderland match.

Here are my replies:

************************

Article Continues Below...



************************

From: Mike

Jeff

Last time I felt the need to write to you regarding (in my opinion) a dubious decision, I felt your reply was acceptable, however not convincing.

Well, you won't be surprised to find me supporting you over the Villain of the Week Steve Bruce. Our ex-player, Darren Bent, colliding with Gomes was deliberate and could not possibly be a red card.

I actually could not see it even as a yellow, unless cards are given for bravery? It was good old fashioned brave goalkeeping.

I respect you for discussing this incident - you have it 100% correct!

Mike

Jeff's reply

Even some Sunderland fans agree with this one. Steve Bruce saw it differently though and many seemed to accept it was a penalty.

************************

From: drasl

The problem with the penalty decision that was actually given, is that most people think Gomes clattered Bent when in fact he did not.

Gomes went in, realised he would not get the ball and did everything he could to avoid Bent. He would have succeeded too but Bent being the cheat that he is (an unavoidable opinion after last weekend's game), he decided to go into Gomes and fetch the penalty.

Jeff's reply

I was unaware Bent had previous. Perhaps he was just doing what most players seem prepared to do, that is chance their arm. Quite often they win and almost always they get away with it.

************************

From: Matt

To be (totally un-)fair, had it been an open goal, it wouldn't necessarily have constituted an 'obvious' goal scoring opportunity...

Especially where Bent at White Hart Lane is concerned!!

I honestly thought guilt got the better of him and he gave Gomes every chance to save it. Maybe that's just me?

Jeff's reply

Very profound and bitter!!

************************

From: A T Hedley

As a Sunderland supporter, I am not in favour of cheats and divers, and Bruce's opinion has little relevance. There are aspects however I would like to query.

I assume that the point of the goal scoring opportunity is only pertinent for the sending off of a goalie?

I am not entirely in agreement with you relating to the suggestion that a penalty was an inappropriate decision.

It did appear with action replays that Bent was in the process of diving but this may not have been the case from the ref's viewpoint, particularly as he did not card Bent.

However, the goalie missed the ball completely and took the player. Had he not done so, Bent might have recovered from his "fall" and got to the ball and scored. Although marginal, I think the ref's decision was correct and his decision is final.

The sooner we have sin-bins for yellow cards where the punishment is meted out during the game in question and therefore there is no tot up to red cards, the better.

The video ref in rugby delays the game not one jot more than the plethora of dissenting players mobbing the ref in football. In fact, I suspect it is a quicker system.

The first non captain protester speaking to the ref would find a free kick given nearer his goal. If football refs had the bottle to implement the laws, they would soon cut out the grandstanding.

Jeff's reply

I agree that sin-bins should be introduced into football and also the ten yard advancement if there is any dissent.

A denial of an obvious goal scoring opportunity is not limited to keepers, it applies to anyone who commits the offence.

I still maintain Bent dived and therefore any contact thereafter was irrelevant. Come on, Bent could not possibly have got up from his dive and played on.

With regard to video replays, fine if the ball is dead but if the ball is still in play, it is totally unworkable.

************************

From: Steve

I don't disagree at all. Bent, in my opinion, cheated. I'm sick to death of this business of "was there contact?". It should be was there sufficient contact to knock him over and was he hit or did he run into the person.

I wish the ref could sin-bin divers for 20 minutes. Putting your team at a disadvantage for that period of time might make the divers think twice.

Jeff's reply

I agree. Some innocents will also get sin-binned, but surely that would discourage anyone from even trying.

************************

From: Rich

Sin-bin divers? Then you get players who haven't dived and deserve a pen being given a twenty min sin-bin. It's not fair really.

Jeff's reply

I take your point, but something has to be done to stamp it out.

************************

From: Stuart Diggle

Bent went down early to make sure he got the pen. Had he tried to stay on his feet, he would have possibly got injured and found that the ref waved play on.

This was a goal scoring opportunity, but yes the ball was going away from goal. However, I think he was far enough ahead of play to get round the keeper, turn and place it into the net.

That said, he would not have been able to stay balanced due to the lateness of the Gomes challenge.

Therefore, he was right to protect himself as well as win a penalty. This is a skill in Serie A.

Jeff's reply

It is cheating in my book. He went down early!! Surely that is a dive. If he had tried to stay on his feet, he may have legitimately won a penalty.

You state that the ball was going away from goal, agreed. The laws therefore state that this is not classed as an obvious goal scoring opportunity.

Yes he might have turned and scored but equally as probable is that he might not have. So therefore it is not obvious.

************************

From: Cec irwins wig

The other thing we seem to have overlooked was the injury to Gordon.

In my opinion, Defoe had plenty of time to lift his leg over Gordon but chose to follow through. Call me cynical but I have looked at this several times and no attempt was made by him to get his leg out of the way.

THOUGHTS?

Jeff's reply

The ball was there to be won. Defoe had every right to go for it. Gordon's injury was very unfortunate, but accidental. It goes with the territory for keepers.

************************

Bookmark and Share

CHECK OUT JEFF WINTER'S OFFICIAL WEBSITE BY CLICKING HERE

DOWNLOAD THE SportingPreview.com TOOLBAR

COMMENT ON THIS ARTICLE

SEND THIS TO A FRIEND
BACK TO VILLAIN OF THE WEEK INDEX
A GUARANTEED PROFIT OF AT LEAST �42.88 ON SOUTHEND v MILTON KEYNES DONS

There's a full round of Football League fixtures this weekend and did you know that it is possible to win money on Friday evening's clash between Southend and Milton Keynes Dons, whatever the result?

The game kicks off at 7.45pm UK Time and we can guarantee you a profit of at least �42.88, whatever the result of the match. All you have to do is follow the simple instructions below and then sit back and enjoy the game. At full-time, you will be at least �42.88 better off, whatever the result of the match.

A GUARANTEED PROFIT OF AT LEAST �42.88 ON SOUTHEND v MILTON KEYNES DONS

Comments On This Article

Mike, November 11, 2009 at 6:48 pm
This one of those occassions when I agree with you 100%.

Gomes was right about it not being a penalty.

Nothing more to add re the Ngog dive - more blatant than the diving bomb.


A T Hedley, November 11, 2009 at 7:14 pm
As a Sunderland supporter I am not in favour of cheats and divers and Bruce\'s opinion has little relevance. There are aspects however I would like to query. I assume that the point of the goal scoring opportunity is only pertinent if this is considered for a sending off of the goalie?

I am not entirely in agreement with you relating to the suggestion that a penalty was an inappropriate decision. It did appear with action replays that Bent was in the process of diving and that may not have been the case from the ref\'s viewpoint, particularly as he did not card Bent, however the goalie missed the ball completely and took the player. Had he not done so Bent might well have recovered from his \"fall\" and got to the ball and scored. Although marginal I think the ref\'s decision was correct and his decision is final.

The sooner we have sin bins for yellow cards where the punishment is meeted out during the game in question and there is therefore no tot up to red cards, the better.

The video ref in rugby delays the game not one jot more than the plethora of dissenting players mobbing the ref in football in fact I suspect it is a quicker system. The first non captain protester speaking to the ref would find a free kick given nearer his goal. If football refs had the bottle to implement the laws they would soon cut out the grandstanding.


Steve, November 11, 2009 at 7:20 pm
I dont disagree at all. Bent in my opinion cheated. I\'m sick to death of this business of \"was there contact\". It should be - was there sufficient contact to knock him over and was he hit or did he run into the person. Bent was flying through the air not to avoid Gomes (he could have hurdled him if that were the case)but because he knew he could fool the Ref.
I wish the ref could sin bin divers for 20 minutes - putting your team at a disadvange for that period of time might well make the divers think twice.


rich, November 11, 2009 at 7:50 pm
Sin Bin divers? then you get players who havent dived and deserve a pen been given a twenty min sin bin, not fair really..


Mico, November 11, 2009 at 8:01 pm
Why is Jeff Winter lying? About seeing the game? About Drogba being level with Brown when Terry headed the ball? Why doesn\'t he simply go to one of the websites that are showing the video and see for himself? He is so far beyond Brown that it is simply not the question. The only question is if Carrick at the far post is playing him on. Luckily we can see by the markings of the goal box that Drogba is a good foot or more offside Drogba should have been called offside and the goal disallowed. But for Winter to be talking about Brown is unbelievable. He says he has seen the slow motion several times, but it seems clear that he has taken this line not through what he has seen with his own eyes but what he has heard or read. Disgusting!



timbo, November 11, 2009 at 8:47 pm
What a pile of garbage. While I agree that Terry did a good job of hiding his typically cynical fouling, his shenanigans are well known, and if the ref couldn\'t see what was happening then the linesman should have been keeping tabs on the situation.

Secondly, if studs showing was the criteria for a free kick I could cite you a dozen or so instances I\'ve seen this year of far worse challenges on United players that went unpunished.

Lastly, you should take a close look at the replay of Drogba and Evans, both in slow-mo and normal speed. Drogba is the biggest cheat in the game, hands down, and it was patently obvious he was hunting for either a penalty of a red card - or both. Take a close look at both his body language and his eyes - Drogba never had any intention of going for the ball, he was far too late on the scene to seriously challenge Evans in the air for the ball. Instead he deliberately charged into the guy in a way that could have caused serious injury to Evans in what was basically a cheap shot by Drogba on a player who\'s attention was completely on the ball and hanging in the air vulnerable and exposed. Drogba sent him flying, spinning him in the air 360 degrees before he landed, then promptly flopped on the ground and went into his usual spastic writhing routine. That Evans foot got planted in Drogba\'s chest there is no doubt, but there is no doubt at all that Evans didn\'t know the first thing about it and that Drogba deliberately ran into him searching for an infringement from the ref. That or he was trying to hurt Evans in a reckless challenge. That he hopefully came off the worse for it is sweet justice, both with the studs on his chest and the yellow card he received for his theatrics.


D K, November 11, 2009 at 9:07 pm
timbo..... you really must be a half wit to believe Evans did not kick out at Drogba and that Drogba ran into him. But hey.... you\'re a Utd fan, so say no more!


pjch, November 11, 2009 at 9:56 pm
re comments sent to me concerning comments I made the other day
Now why are we always talking about the refs all the time. Its because they get things wrong.They get in the wrong positions and the linesmen can\'t keep up with play. Thought the linesmen should be level with the last defender so making offside decisions easier to make. And what about the penalty for Liverpool - not to mention Cole throwing himself up in the air when tackled by Fletcher. And Carragher was sent off for doing what he did to Owen when Liverpool played Fulham.

Too many wrong decisions are being made by Refs I only hope one isn\'t made at the end of the season on the last day when some team gets relegated by someone who has missed the obvious. The FA want respect for refs but to me it has to be earned by being right with decisions.

Lets have technology to help us It doesn\'t take that long to sort out contentious decisions



Reply:- You should be put in charge of the FA and the Referees. Teach the linesmen hw to keep up with ball that is kicked at 40 mph as well, even Usain Bolt could not do that!!!



Please read my previous comments on all the incidents you mention. Why not take up reffing yourself. Firstly though please get someone top teach you the laws of the game!!!

top teach should have been to teach
And my comment about the linesmen was not asking them to chase a ball at 40mph All they have to do is be level with the last defender when the ball is played.
Sorry but I have watched football for over 50 years and refs get things wrong. What about goals that were given when it was clearly not one (last season I think) or a goal that has been disallowed when it comes back out after hitting the the back of the net(this season I think)
Knowing the laws Well I do know 2 yellows equal a red Can\'t remember who the ref was that gave 3 yellows Maybe you could let me know


question, November 12, 2009 at 12:47 am
If Steve Bruce does not understand what is a denial of a goal scoring opportunity then surely the referee does not either


David Reilly, November 12, 2009 at 1:29 am
Fletcher\'s foot was not that high,th ball was there to be won and cole did not make a good attempt at it,only his reaction afterwards!for the goal,Atkinson was standing behind Joe Cole,What was that about?? A referee who is refereeing in the Premier League should have the common sense to move and try see the play immediatley,it should be human nature to him to want to see the play.Also,Brown was trying to cover ground across the goal and he magically ends up on the floor,ref should have immediately asked the question how did he end up there?surely he wanted to clear the ball??Joe Cole was in the way,that\'s why he had no answers! His assistants didn\'t help him either,for the penlty claim he\'s not that far away and they way Valencia falls it\'s obvious he\'s being held


stuart diggle, November 12, 2009 at 1:30 am
bent went down early to make sure he got the pen. if he tried to stay on feet, he would have possibly got injured and found that the ref waved play on. this was a goalscoring opportunity, but yes the ball was going away from goal. however, i think he was afr enough ahead of play to get round teh keeper , turn and place it into the net. that said, he would not have been able to saty balanced due to the lateness of gomez challenge. therefore, right to protect himself aswell as win a penalty. this is a skill in serie \'a\'.


Ted Perechalli, November 12, 2009 at 3:54 am
You are talking rubbish, Jeff Winter, and both you and I know it.


Diydis, November 12, 2009 at 4:12 am
I agree about the Bent penalty, he was always going to go down because he had lost the ball, he is a cheat and to do it against his former club shows the class of the lad, we are well rid.


Cec irwins wig, November 12, 2009 at 9:21 am
The other think we seem to have overlooked was the injury to Gordon..In my opinion Defoe had plenty of time to lift his leg over Gordon but ! chose to follow through.Call me cynical but..I have looked at this several times and no attempt is made by him to get his leg out of the way.. THOUGHTS ???


Boby, November 12, 2009 at 10:00 am
From Jeff Winter analysis the there was nothing wrong from the match. If anything he must be wondering why the noise. By the way was he a referee at some point, does any body know!


Matt, November 12, 2009 at 12:19 pm
To be (totally un-)fair, had it been an open goal, it wouldn\'t necessarily have constituted an \'obvious\' goalscoring opportunity... Especially where Bent at White Hart Lane are concerned!! I honestly thought guilt got the better of him, and he gave Gomes every chance to save it... maybe that\'s just me?


drasl, November 12, 2009 at 3:59 pm
The problem with the penalty decision that was actually given, is that most people think Gomes clattered Bent. When in fact he did not. Gomes went in, realized he would not get the ball and did everything he could to avoid Bent. He would have succeded to but Bent being the cheat that he is ( Yes unavoidable opinion after last weekends game ) decided to go into Gomes and fetch the penalty.


Red Rupert, November 13, 2009 at 9:32 pm
Good to see not everyone is taken in by Jeff\'s \"expert\" opinion. He calls us fans for being one-eyed when he is doing just the same in support of a referee. The ref was a shocker. Actually, he probably isn\'t really - he just made sure no decisions went United\'s way (like the ref did in the Liverpool game) since Fergie\'s remarks about Alan Wiley. They\'ve clearly decided to take their own points deduction out on United.


Superalf, November 18, 2009 at 12:01 am
I don\'t quite agree with MICO but I can see what the issue is about. Being on the pitch to judge the play with split second decision is not going to be an easy job. But you are looking at the incidence again on slow motion you have the advantage that the main referee during the match does not have but what happened to those on the side lines? Perhaps technology should place part in modern football refereeing and an assisting tool.


John Snelly, November 18, 2009 at 12:21 am
Darren Bent
What I cannot work out , following the Eduardo situation, is why the FA have not reviewed the incident and issued Bent with a warning and possible suspension. Let\'s cut to the chase - it is cheating. Full Stop.
And if Bent is cheating, Bruce is bleating. Gomes was just competing

Let\'s rid the game of obvious cheats




Mark Howells, November 18, 2009 at 11:52 am
They say the best refs went unoticed during games, yet everybody knows who Jeff Winter is. Point proven.


 
Name:
Email:
Your Comment:


   COLUMNISTS


© All written site content is copyright SportingPreview.com 2009, unless otherwise stated, and is not to be used without prior permission.
  SPORTS NEWS
  Cricket
  Football
  Horse Racing
  Industry News
  Novelty
  Other Sports
  Rugby
  Tennis
  DAILY
  Racing Tips
  Greyhounds
  Paddy Power
  Premium Tips
  WEEKLY
  Paddy Power
  Betfair Previews
  MORE
  Betting Diary
  Guaranteed Profit Bets
  MISCELLANEOUS
  Links
  RSS Feeds
   Sitemap | Search Site | Terms and Privacy | Set as Homepage | Contact
This website designed, maintained and managed by Waking Lion ©2009